EC --
Wanted to thank you for posting the entry on
your blog about Cafe Suron. I chose this venue for our "bonus" meetup this month. It was, overall, a fairly good experience.
I had a bit of trouble finding parking in the area at first, but that was mostly because I was unfamiliar with the neighborhood -- I eventually discovered that there was plenty of street parking on Sheridan that was free and available. (Being a suburbanite, parking is my greatest anxiety and annoyance of coming into the city.)
The atmosphere is nice -- though I have to say I was slightly disappointed that the fountain (shown on their website) wasn't on. The host also seated our party right next to the door, which was great for visibility as people came in, but bad as I caught most of the cold air coming in through the front door. Only other small complaint I can make about the venue is that, because of the high ceilings, the accoustics were not so great. It was very loud and sometimes difficult to hear what someone at one end of the table was saying (there were 7 of us in all).
Our waiter was nice, but the service was very slow. I can't be sure if it was because they were fairly busy (seemed so for a Tuesday night; at 7 PM, the place was about 3/4 full), or if it could be attributed to a "slower" European attitude. I was going to bring in some wine, but left it in my car. No one else BYO'ed, so I decided to leave it and try some of the non-alcoholic offerings. The Persian tea I had first was very strong and somewhat earthy/minty. Not too bad.
We decided to order some appetizers to share. Since you made a comment about the quail, we ordered the grilled quail appetizer, which was fantastic. I especially liked the spinach the quail came on -- it had a great flavor to it, sort of garlicky and savory. We also ordered the Sampler Platter, which came with Dolmeh, Hummus, Baba-Ganush, Kashke-Bademjan and Persian Salad. The Dolmeh (stuffed grape leaves) and Hummus were fantastic. I think I can actually say that was some of the best hummus I've ever had.
We ended up having to wait quite a while for the dinner entrees -- I think one of our guys said it was something like 45 minutes before the entrees finally came out. Honestly, if it hadn't been for the interesting conversation, I probably would have been very annoyed. As it was, I had noticed we had been waiting an unusually long time.
Almost everyone ordered a combination plate -- lamb, chicken, scallops, or some combination thereof, and quite amusingly, everyone's dinner was pretty much plated the same -- (just like the Barg, if you look at Cafe Suron's
menu). I don't think it gets much more accurate than that, other than that everyone had dill rice, which was green, instead of the white rice pictured there.
I, on the other hand, decided on the Mahi-Mahi, which, upon plating, looked pretty much like the Hawaiian Tilapia featured on their website. I also received an extra-large side of dill rice. The dill rice was really nice and mild. I particularly was pleased because I'm not a huge dill fan. The saffron was nice, too. I can't say as much about the Mahi-Mahi. Not a whole lot of flavor going on there; wouldn't order that again.
I didn't try any of the other dishes (i.e., the lamb or chicken or scallops), but everyone else seemed pretty happy with their entrees. The comment that stuck out the most was that the lamb had a different kind of flavor -- it was very tender and almost beef-like.
We decided to order dessert as well; they had six choices: a pear tart, vanilla custard, key lime cheesecake, taramisu, a chocolate-type cheesecake, and a berry tart with a cheese filling. Around the table, we had the pear tart, key lime cheesecake and the vanilla custard.
I, personally had the custard, which was served with a criss-cross of cinnamon and pistaschio crumbs. Good combination, simple, not overwhelmingly fantastic, but tasty. I also tasted the Key Lime cheesecake, which was much better, by far. I've had Key Lime Cheesecake in the past before, though (not here) and am kind of partial to it. Coffee was very decent as well.
Overall --- while I'd rather have had a warmer table and slightly faster service, I'd say the meal was worthwhile, all things considered. The waiter was kind enough to split our entire table's checks, so that earned him a couple extra bucks. Overall, with tax & tip, my dinner came to about $30. Not bad at all for a three-course meal.
If you go, be prepared to wait for your food. Also: if you BYO, the restaurant has a $4 corkage fee. I didn't think the BYO was necessary, but it might make your wait a bit more tolerable ...
ETA: Two other comments to make: 1) The [ladies] bathroom was very nice and clean. There's definitely something to be said for that ...
/George Constanza
2) They do accept credit cards now; one of the people in my party paid with a credit card.