My wife and I live near Ashland and Clybourn and for a romantic dinner, our local favorite is Luna Caprese. LC doesn't get that much love on LTH (though it has been mentioned several times for its excellent housemade pasta.) We have eaten there several times and really enjoyed it. The atmosphere is dark and romantic, and has the feel of a hidden gem. We enjoyed some wonderful housemade ravioli and fettucini as well as a very nice eggplant appetizer and a couple of drinks. The service was very personable and we lingered to enjoy the atmosphere. I am pretty sure the total bill was less than $75 including tip (although we did not order more than two drinks.)
If you are willing to spend a bit more, GNR Sweets and Savories is not too far away. Other places in the area include Filippo's and Pequods.
Best,
Veeral
Luna Caprese
2239 N Clybourn Ave
Chicago, IL 60614
(773) 281-4825
www.lunacaprese.com
PS I wanted to post this earlier today but the site was down. With the good memories in my head, we decided to go back there tonight. We started with an excellent lentil soup that was very flavorful. I had the pappardelle with porcini mushrooms in a cream sauce - a very scrumptious savory dish that totally hit the spot on this cold night. My wife had the nightly special of asparagus and ricotta ravioli, which was also excellent. The other special was home made lasagna, which sounded (and looked) excellent, but I'll have to save that for another night. The atmosphere was a bit louder tonight and the little space was packed, but we had excellent service and enjoyed our little hidden gem.