JeffB wrote:Seafood Alfredo? Don't tell Tony (no, not Tony Shaloub, Don Tony Trismegistus -- though Shaloub's character in Big Night probably would not have been able to avoid a confrontation upon receiving the request). You are lucky not to bear the cross that some others here hold. Illogical tradition perhaps, but it's something to do.
Ah, and you call me a rabble rouser, Don Giuffré...
Fettucine Alfredo is a celebration of dairy: butter and parmesan is one of the old basic dressings of pasta, to which then the cream was added to complete the trinity of dairy products that are in especially ample measures the distinctive dressing of the pasta in this dish. Within the Italian repertoire, this preparation is already excessive but such excess is appropriate once in a while. Further additions add to the volume of the dish and presumably to the 'deliciousness' for some but from the perspective of others they necessarily detract from the focus on how the three dairy products work together.
***
From a Scicaghitano or Statiunitese perspective, adding meat or seafood or pesto-primavera-quattro-formaggi or whatever to something 'Alfredo' style is not bucking any Italian tradition but rather conforming to the American habit of combo-primo-secondo ersatz-Italienische Eintopf-creations. Which is, of course, fine, if one likes that sort of thing, and obviously lots of people do very much.
Tous les goûts sont dans la nature.***
I think Alfredo preps have the distinction of being the single biggest tragedy in Americanized, Italian-American cooking a la Olive Garden and the like. When its bad, it's really, really bad (and it's nearly always bad)...
Here's everything you need to know about Sabatino's Alfredo: patron asks for some Alfredo sauce on the side. Response: we don't have a big bucket of Alfredo sauce, Alfredo is a preparation that is made a la minute and per order.
I've never contemplated for very long what it is that so often renders
alfredo alla Mericana a toxic substance but what you say above makes me realise that this use of Alfreddy as a sort of all-purpose sauce requires it be made in somehow stabilised batches, a process which -- however it be achieved -- must needs destroy the essential quick and fresh quality of the properly made dairy overdose.
That's very good to hear about Sabatino's unwillingness and/or inability to acquiesce to something that doesn't make sense; satisfying reasonable requests is something a restaurant should always strive to do but in this case, the fact that they do things the right way just made it impossible (or at least very impractical).
I still haven't been to Sabatino's but the evidence continues to mount that they really know what they're doing. One of these days, I'll go... and maybe even order pasta...
***
I also haven't been to "
La Lucé [sic] and so far don't feel any particular urge to go there but I must say that it's an extremely handsome looking restaurant, especially in its setting by the elevated train-line. It's also nice to hear that they are able and willing to accommodate a special request with apparent ease and success. They must be keeping their customers happy to have survived in that (still somewhat) out-of-the-way location; certainly the reports on this board have been for the most part quite positive.
But what is that ridiculous acute accent doing on the final <e> of the name?
Antonius
Alle Nerven exzitiert von dem gewürzten Wein -- Anwandlung von Todesahndungen -- Doppeltgänger --
- aus dem Tagebuch E.T.A. Hoffmanns, 6. Januar 1804.
________
Na sir is na seachain an cath.