Circling back to this with a report since I started the (now split) thread. In general, I wasn't nearly as impressed with Vittel, and although I would return, having had a the vast majority of the menu I will definitely wait until there are some significant changes. I am rooting for the place though, as it's a fun space, and is ambitious, and the kind of place I would like to see more of in Chicago.
My now-fading memories are, in order:
1) Rough service, other than the somm who was a very helpful, genial guy, and an interesting wine list. We had a rose champagne and I think a sangiovese that he guided us to. And some Amaros and Byrhh by the fire.
2) Good room/outside area. The fireplace has been described, I think, but it is really nice and we were there on one of these unseasonably 50 degree Winter days that we've been having. A little awkward as there was a couple of women out there having an intimate discussion and we had to muscle in a bit for blanket use and space, and then our conversations kind of clashed, but still a nice concept. I am interested in seeing what they do with the yard in the Summer - hopefully some outdoor dining options. I liked the spirit and simple clean feel of the dining room also. It was a Saturday and a packed with a bumping crowd having a good time, and (once we got some attention and drinks) were carried by that despite some grouchiness from service issues.
3) Salty skate wing - nuff said, this wasn't edible, and too bad cause it seemed like it had potential.
4) Meh egg/chicken thigh and lamb - disappointing as I had heard good things about the omelette and the lamb sounded good. The former was lacking in chicken and any real assertive flavors and the lamb was underseasoned and overdone in my opinion.
5) Get the salsify dumplings and maitake - great dishes; really wonderful. Just bursting with flavor.
6) Comically small octopus portion - too bad because it was good. We got 2 orders for the 4 of us and each person got two one inch nubs along with the ruffage. I don't like to beat on places for portion size because often we end up stuffed because of, well, big eyes primarily, but also being served too much, but the general theme here was smaller sizes (both in the small and large items). We ordered everything on the a la carte menu but the sweetbreads (a shame, but someone in our group with an aversion), including two octo and two lamb and still came out with some room left (though no need for chili-cheese fries at Floyd's on the way home, like after one of my Bonsoiree meals). As an aside, can anyone explain octopus pricing to me? It is often very expensive at restaurants (Bella Notte appetizer is a tasty good value at $11 or $12), though not so much at the fish monger. Extra prep time?
7) Odd desserts. I don't remember them very well, other than some interesting textures - perhaps a beet flan? In any event, no chocolate bombe here. Or anything else you've heard of. This could be fun but I wasn't blown away with these.
Again, the uneven service won't keep me away as our visit occurred really early (hopefully) in Elske's life cycle, but the uneven preps will. For now. Like I noted, I am interested to see what they do outside in the Summer.