Vital Information wrote:I'm not 100%, but pretty sure that boti refers to chunks of bone-less meat, not to a specific type of seasoning.
You are correct sir. Specifically "boti" refers to boneless chunks of thigh or leg meat when you're talking chicken, or boneless chunks of leg or shank meat from our four-legged friends.
I agree, BTW - "boti" to me has always just been sort of "hunk of meat". You eat curries (goat curries usually), you pour some for your friend onto his rice, and he says "put a coupla botis in there, will ya?". You go out for goat biryani, and you complain "bleddy restaurantwallahs, skimping on the meat as usual, hardly found a boti in there". To me it was almost always used for meat, goat or beef - hardly ever referred to chicken, really. But it makes sense at Khan's - its boneless chunks that just happen to be chicken. However, there is no specific seasoning for a boti - it can be the green-masala-stuff that works so well at Khan's, or (more commonly) it will be the red-masala stuff you'll get most other places.
Seekh kebab almost universally refers to seasoned, minced meat hand-molded onto a stick & cooked on a grill.
Chapli kebab almost universally refers to seasoned, minced meat shaped into a patty & cooked on a griddle.
Agree with both these defintions too.. though, BTW, I too think Chapli is almost never chicken. Or it shouldnt be, at any rate, not unless they specifically claim "chicken chapli kabab" (IMHO). If you see just "sheekh kabab" or "chapli kabab" on a menu, it ought to be *real* meat

Thus goat, or lamb, or beef, depending on where you are... if its chicken it ought to specifically say so.
Shami kebabs are a more confusing beast: allegedly they're supposed to be similar to chapli kebabs, but I've often seen the term used to refer to seekh kebabs.
Disagree with this one - I'll second ab on this. To me "shami kababs" are minced-meat kababs, and very very different from chaplis (the texture is unmistakably different, and usually there are some different seasonings and additional ingredients, to help retain the shape). To me shami's are generally disk-shaped, but dont *have* to be - individualists may go spherical, though its frowned upon

(Also, BTW, to me a "nargisi kabab" is a shami-kabab with a hard-boiled egg in it - the actual meat part is identical, minced, same ingredients etc).
All of the above kebabs can be made of different kinds of meat (generally lamb or chicken in India, often beef in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, etc.), with different seasonings, served with different chutneys, and so on.
True - but again, IMHO, when it says kabab it invariably means *meat* - which excludes chicken unless specified. That is, IMHO you will almost never see "sheekh kabab" anywhere which is chicken - unless it specifically says "chicken sheekh kabab".
c8w