Sometime in the last few months Taqueria Santa Rita was replaced by El Puerto Mariscos and Grill. A banner referring to mariscos has been up for a while, but I did not take a closer look until after the Santa Rita sign was taken down.
The two storefronts were gutted and completely rebuilt. Tables now have granite slab tops with wood chairs complete with padded seats. While Santa Rita had moved to be more than a taqueria, this edition is definitely a restaurant.
My wife and I had a somewhat late lunch there today. The chips were not the crispiest, perhaps due high humidity, and the table salsa was quite mild. There were two different Mexican bottled hot sauces on the table while two other sauces were available in squirt bottles.
From the two menu pages of seafood I had the pulpo ranchero platter. Tender pieces of octopus in ranchero sauce along with a plentiful amount of lightly cooked yellow, red and green bell peppers. The salad was the common lightly dressed iceberg lettuce with slices of overly mature cucumber and a slice of bright red tomato. The platter also had mediocre rice and poor French fries. There was a choice of bread or tortillas.
Another two pages of menu had many standard Mexican items. My wife had a torta with beef milanesa. My bite of the beef was crisp and flavorful. Her horchata had good flavor with a fair but not excessive amount of cinnamon.
The open kitchen had a trompo of pork al pastor. No sign of pineapple or onion at the top, though. The menus had a number of items blanked out and a bunch of price changes hand written in. One oddity that may reflect sloppy proofreading or English limitations is that barbacoa was translated in two places as broiled beef. All of the other customers appeared to be Mexican.
I definitely want to give the al pastor a shot as well as some of the other seafood dishes.
Signage indicates open seven days a week. Yelp listing says closed Monday.
El Puerto Mariscos & Grill
2752-5 West Lawrence Avenue
Chicago, IL 60625
773-930-3160
BYOB