Went here with the girlfriend last night. We got there around 7 and it was nearly empty -- only 2 other groups. It has a reasonably nice interior and the garden is great. There's wood everywhere, and long communal tables (feels a lot like Avec, though the wood is about there the similarity ends).
The service was about what you would expect from a brand new place -- attentive (maybe overly so) but a tad sloppy. I guess it's always going to be a bit awkward when there are more waitstaff than customers.
On to the food. We usually like to just share appetizers, so we figured the menu of small plates and large plates would be good. We started with the salmon tartare on caper bellinis and the duck rilletes tartine (both $12, I think). The salmon was good, the capers really came through, but it wasn't much food. The duck was also very good. There was a lot of flavor, with the fruit (apricot, maybe) really working.
Next we got a lobster flatbread ($12). Now, at the bluebird a few blocks down damen, an $11 flatbread is easily a full meal. At Duchamp, it was barely even an appetizer. Just 5 thin slices, with almost no lobster at all. I liked the idea of garnishing it with celery leaves, the taste worked well, but at that price, one would hope for either more or better ingredients.
Last, we had the cheese plate. The fruit bread it came with seemed home baked and was fantastic. Again, for $12, though, it just didn't seem like enough food. We got 2 small slices each of three cheeses (a manchego, a bleu goat cheese, and a triple-creme). They were fine, but nothing mind-blowing.
If we had been in the loop or another area where you at least know the property is expensive, the prices might have been expected. But at Damen and Armitage, I guess we had hoped for a restaurant that would give us a reasonable meal. There are any number of restaurants just down the street -- Le Bouchon, the Bluebird, Jane's, Mado -- that for similar prices will actually serve you a full meal. And for all the similarities with Avec -- the decor, the menu style, even the food choices to some extent -- at Avec, you at least know you'll leave full.
We quit on the meal before dessert, so I can't comment on that part of the menu, but given the skimpy portions we'd gotten so far, we figured we should just take off and finish the meal elsewhere. Maybe the large plates are more filling -- at twice the prices of the small plates, I hope so. But the small plates are really just small appetizers. At $90 for two people (including a $35 bottle of wine), you shouldn't leave hungry.
I don't see this place surviving. For as far north as they are, and given the number of places they're competing with, I just don't see how they can charge the prices that they do for such skimpy portions. On the other hand, the food was reasonably good, and it's probably easier to give people more food than to get a better chef.