Took my roommate to try this place out tonight. It was great, and I'm really glad I came.
We got the green bean curd, salt miner's chicken small plate, fish in chili bean sauce, and the squash.
Green Bean Curd - I agree. Sort of boring. Not bad, but pretty much just an excuse to sop up the tasty chili oil they had.
Salt Miner's Chicken - Awesome! This is Da Pan Ji - Big Plate Chicken. In China, I typically only ordered this in Xinjiang-style restaurants. I've never seen this in America (maybe I just haven't recognized its place on Chinatown menus), but I was so psyched when I realized what it was. I haven't had this in years, and it was a great surprise. Like other posters have said, this is basically a chicken stew in a red, chili broth with a healthy amount of peppers and sichuan peppercorns. It was good, though definitely not the best version I've had. I wish there were more potatoes on the plate they gave us. And in the past, there have been more big pieces of chicken (these were all small pieces). The chicken also wasn't quite as juicy as my favorite renditions have been (which makes me wonder how long this has been stewing before they served it to us). If I understand right, traditionally the noodles are not served with the chicken. Once the table has eaten most of the chicken and vegetables in the stew, the noodles are brought out, and the diners then sop up the stew with the fresh noodles. These noodles were tasty, but they were smaller (a bit shriveled), less fresh-tasting, and less numerous than I remember.
Fish in Chili Bean Sauce - When we were ordering, the staff were worried that we were ordering a bit too authentic. I guess we had that "white people in the headlights" look. They suggested a dish that had fillets, because "Americans don't like whole fish and like fillets." We insisted and got the whole fish. Perfectly cooked. Moist and delicious with a great chili bean sauce.
Squash - Roommate wasn't in an eggplant mood, so we asked the waiter, and he recommended the squash. I really enjoyed it. Not exciting, but a solid vegetable dish. The squash was soft, but not too soft. Served with small shreds of shrimp. And I really liked how it was slightly bitter. My roommate wished we had gotten the eggplant :\
All in all, a really satisfying meal. Not on my top 5 meals in Chinatown or anything, but I'm looking forward to coming back and checking out more of the menu. Admittedly, the spice levels were very low, but that was partly because we didn't insist on non-white spice levels, and because my roommate mentioned that she doesn't like very spicy food. So it was totally understandable. I want to go back, order the Da Pan Ji larger portion with more aggressive levels of spice and see how that compares to what I remember. I'll be back.