I have not heard so many good comments about Francesca's Forno, so I was a little nervous when friends chose it for a birthday celebration last night. I guess I can say that it was better than expected, but certainly not a place I intend to visit again.
The noise issue is for real. I doubt that I have been in a louder restaurant in Chicago. It's extremely difficult to have a conversation, and impossible if you're on one end of the group and a friend is on the other end of a group of 6. This alone would keep me from returning on a weekend evening.
Foodwise, I tried the roasted beets, goat cheese and hazelnuts. This is served in a soup cup which in this instance was good because there might have been a little too much oil, but thankfully most of that oil dripped to the bottom of the cup. The beets were diced small and were very perfectly roasted, flavorful and the dish was pretty tasty, although there was not enough goat cheese.
I really enjoyed the Ricotta e Miele - Ricotta with Acacia honey, sea salt and ground black pepper. While this is not the best Ricotta you will find, it was quite good and served with the perfect amount of honey to make it just slightly sweet. A little more sea salt would have been nice to accentuate the flavors more, but this was very good nonetheless.
FF really screwed up with their tomato dishes, in my opinion. The Caprese salad, which I did not order, comes with beefsteak tomatoes. The Panzanella salad on the other hand comes with varieties of heirloom tomatoes. They should reverse this to appropriately highlight the heirloom tomatoes, but oh well.
I opted for the Panzanella and it was a little below average. First, there was simply too much vinegar. Equally bad - some of the heirlooms were a little over-ripe, others under-ripe, so maybe the vinegar did not steal so much flavor anyway. The menu also indicates that the salad is served with a warm Gorgonzola dressing which I asked for on the side. Why ruin the taste of the heirlooms with so much vinaigrette and then with blue cheese? I tasted the dressing and it was very thin and not impressive. Well, at least the bread in the salad was nicely textured, not crisp yet a little bite was left in the bread.
The Pizza Salsiccia e Uova featured Soppressata, one fried egg (sunny side up) and Piave Vecchio. I imagined a perfect combination of flavors, but turned out to be only average. The crust was a little too oily, and did not offer much in the way of texture or flavor. The Soppressata was far from the best I have had, and there was so little of it (and slightly overcooked). Seemingly a great combination turned out to be a failure in execution.
A friend of mine had a prosciutto-wrapped trout. The waiter raved about this dish, but none of us were enamored. Little in the way of flavor and there was so much salt added to the dish to ruin what was otherwise a well cooked piece of fish.
On the other hand, I tried a friend's skirt steak and it was cooked medium rare as requested and was perfectly tender and very nicely flavored.
We skipped dessert and headed over to Hot Chocolate which was as usual, outstanding.