If I recall correctly (It was a LONG time ago, early 70s, I believe) and I'm thinking about the right place, Mama Lena's served family-style meals, on long tables for larger groups, with several smaller tables scattered around. I believe everybody would be served the same antipasti, and primi (with second helpings), altho there might have been choices for second courses. Reservations were required and they were often difficult to get. Altho I remember no particular dishes, I believe it was typical Southern-Italian-American style cuisine, similar to Tufano's or Febo's or (and here's another memory) Club El Bianco.
When the Italian Door opened, we reserved a table to introduce some friends to this kind of experience, since it was advertised as "Family-style" similar to Mama Lena's. I remember absolutely nothing of the food other than the fact that my impressions were totally negative from zuppa to noci, and this was long before I had any real experience with la cucina italiana vera. What I do remember was that two young men were running (if you can call it that) the place, and they didn't have a clue on how to manage a restaurant or to structure and cook a meal. A lot of good intentions, but execution was nil. Much apologies to our friends afterwards, and regrets (in retrospect) that we didn't have something like LTH to check up on things like this. I don't think the responsible parties ever got their act together because, I believe, the Italian Door was locked and shuttered shortly thereafter.
"The fork with two prongs is in use in northern Europe. In England, they’re armed with a steel trident, a fork with three prongs. In France we have a fork with four prongs; it’s the height of civilization." Eugene Briffault (1846)