I wonder if fame has changed the quality at cakelove? I was in DC this weekend and stopped in, and what I ordered was horrid. admittedly, we didn't try a wide variety, so maybe it's a cupcake-specific problem, but yikes.
Mr. Sweetsalty and I split two cupcakes- one chocolate w/lemon frosting, and one chocolate w/peanut butter frosting. The cupcakes themselves tasted completely plastic-y, nothing really redeeming about them. As I said, perhaps it is a chocolate cupcake problem, since we didn't try other flavors. The frosting was appalling- tasted VERY much like it was made from shortening, as it was just greasy and really quite flavorless. The peanut butter frosting was marginally better- we both agreed this was most likely d/t the addition of the peanut butter fat, and probable reduction in shortening in the frosting.
Overall, I found the quality to be so completely poor, I would not go back, even to try another option- it didnt' seem to be a preparation problem (burnt cupcakes, too chewy, etc), but a quality-of-ingredients issue. IMO, this is made all the more unforgivable by the sky-high prices charged.