This is my first post to LTHForum/kc. I, too, am an old Chicago boy (1957-'75, '87-'96, '98-2000). Been in the KC area (JoCo) since '03.
I am very fussy about my pizza. You should know ... I never saw a "deep dish Chicago pizza" until I was well into my teens. I grew up on the SW Side, and all of the neighborhood mom-and-pop pizzerias served delicious Sicilian-style thin-crust pies. As tasty as a pan pie can be if it's made right, I still call that a "Chicago tourist pizza".
My partner and I spent a couple of years, trying various pizza joints around KC ... and were almost always disappointed. Then we discovered Papa Murphy's take-n-bake, paper-thin "DeLite" pizza. It's a good product. Two or three of your favorite ingredients, and you're on your way. Here's our special secret, though ... and this comes from a retired Chicago pizza shop owner I used to know: Add 1/3 cup to 1/2 cup of grated Asiago to the top of that pie, then pop that sucker in the oven and bake until it's golden brown and bubbly. The result will approximate the type of pizza I grew up enjoying. Of course, you have to slice it into squares, not wedges. I don't know why, but it tastes different.
We've also discovered a pleasant surprise: Our friendly neighborhood HyVee store will bake you a really fine pizza. In fact, when the weather is too warm to bake a Papa Murphy's, HyVee's Italian department is our go-to for a pizza that will hit the spot. They use a combo of tasty cheeses, plus good fresh ingredients, and a crispy crust.
We also like D'Bronx or Waldo Pizza if we want to go somewhere away from home and sit down.