I'm assuming you know that food is simply different up there, right? Egg noodles and ketchup as spaghetti marinara different. I haven't stopped at the few pasty shops on the main strip. I always want to try the Dobbers pasty place and there is also another one that looks like it is more "homey." But anyway, for fun, with a chance of being something decent, I stopped at Poor Boy Roy's one time. It's a tiny little place trying to bring a taste of New Orleans via fast-ish food. Shrimp Po Boy's, fried oysters, fried fish, etc. It's tiny. Very casual. If keeping in mind that food is just simply different up there, you might find Poor Boy Roy's ok. Don't get the fried oysters. They are food service breaded, frozen things. We didn't finish our order. Food is just different up there. Also, I seem to remember the fried walleye being VERY salty. I'd try the place again. The owner was a youngish guy who was very eager to recommend things, and answered all my "silly" questions. Remember, food is just different up there. There is also a Frozen Custard and maybe waffle place - found it - Storheim's. It's across the street from the Burger King / Gas Station we always stop at for a potty / coffee / silly lottery ticket break. I always wanna stop there, but for some reason, I haven't. Looks like they have a bunch of flavors:
http://www.storheims.com/Just remember, ice cream and belgian waffle SOUNDS great, but food is just different up there. If it wound up being dairy queen soft serve and eggos from the toaster, I just would not be surprised at ALL.
Food is just different up there.
For FUN, in Niagara, there is what looks like an old time wild west lookin multi store place that has a candy shop, ice cream, and I'm pretty sure a food place in it. When you are heading north, it's on the right side of the road. You'll see it if you are driving during the day. Pretty sure it's in Niagara. You'll see it. Niagara speed limit is 25 mph.
We travel through Iron Mountain probably 20 times per year, but rarely stop for anything other than coffee / potty. I'd really like to hear about where you go tho. Sorry I don't have much to add, but maybe this helps a tiny bit.
Just remember, food is different up there.
Hmm - quick search shows PBR has a site:
http://poorboyroys.com/
We cannot be friends if you do not know the difference between Mayo and Miracle Whip.