Whole Foods in River Forest was offering "Seaside rugged mature English cheddar" this week for $5.99 / lb*, and I imagine it's carried at other locations as well. This is a remarkable cow's milk cheese. It combines the creamy sharpness of some of my favorite cheddars with the crumble and tang of a pamigiano, and the flavor is somewhere in between. Intriguingly, the cheese crunches on the back teeth because the aging process and conditions cause little pockets of calcium and sodium crystals to form.
I can't find much on this cheese or the cheesemaker behind it, but I encourage you to explore it; I think it's a very rewarding buy. Here is a recent mention:
http://www.contracostatimes.com/pleasanton/ci_8487518A page featuring the stunning Dorset countryside setting of the dairy estate, Ashley Chase:
http://www.farmhousecheesemakers.com/ch ... se_estate/*that's what the sign said; my packet was .55 lb and initially rang up as $5.99, but when I called them on it they gave it to me by weight. Whether the sign or the cashier was in error, I'm not sure. Worth it either way as far as I'm concerned.