Bridgestone wrote:Is it possible to overreduce stock? And, if so, can overreduction be cured by simply adding water?
I've made a few heavy duty stocks (10-12 pounds of meat and bones per gallon of water) and reduced some of them heavily. However, once or twice, the syrupy reduction ended up cloying, sweet(ish)/sour(ish) and, for lack of a better description, almost tongue-coating in the sauce I used it in.
I interpret this as perhaps overreduction. Am I wrong?
Can it be prevented?
I don't think there is a right and wrong here; one should just go by what tastes good. Very heavily reduced stocks will indeed have the intense, syrupy, maybe cloying properties you describe - usually too much so for most dishes. A concentrated glace is usually best (to me) when diluted with a dry white wine.
The same principle applies when it comes to reconstituting a concentrated glace with water to make stock... go with what tastes good to you. To me, a reconstituted glace is never going to taste as balanced and flavorful as a pure stock. It always seems just a little flat to me. But it's still going to be darn good, so if you need the freezer space it might be worth it to sacrifice a little perfection.
...defended from strong temptations to social ambition by a still stronger taste for tripe and onions." Screwtape in
The Screwtape Letters by CS Lewis
Fuckerberg on Food