I have read this whole thread and some of the others, and looked at dozens of recipes, and there are a lot of conflicting opinions. None of them quite cover exactly what I'm after. I'm planning to make some fruit ice creams (peach and blueberry, separately or together), and I don't really have the time or patience to do head-to-head comparisons, so I hope some of you have. :-)
What I want: Creamy texture, intense fresh-fruit flavor, storability.
Questions:Eggs or no eggs?
If eggs, raw or cooked?
If no eggs or raw eggs, does it still need to cure?
Stabilizers or no stabilizers?
Best ratio of milk to cream?
Cooked fruit or raw?
Add the fruit to the base, stir it in when partly frozen or some combination?
Best sweeteners?
Discussion: I would normally make a custard base, but I came across this
article that suggests Philly style is better with fruit. I'm also intrigued by
Ben & Jerry's recipe that calls for whole raw eggs. (I am not worried about the health implications of raw eggs.) That has the advantage of being trivially easy and fast: No cooking, no waiting (except for macerating the fruit).
By "stabilizers," I don't mean commercial ice-cream stabilizer, but supermarket ingredients or liquor. I'm not always happy about the mouthfeel of stabilized ice creams -- some of them seem gummy, especially if gelatin or something like that is used.
Kennyz's gorgeous looking blueberry ice cream upthread cooks the fruit and adds it directly to the base before churning. Ben & Jerry's macerates raw fruit, adds the liquid to the base and stirs the pulp in at the end. I want the ice cream itself to be fruit flavored, not vanilla ice cream with fruit bits, although I wouldn't mind some fruit bits if they can be kept from turning into hard icy chunks. I'm a little concerned that cooking the fruit might take away some of the fresh-fruit flavor I'm looking for.
I have available: white sugar, brown sugar, raw sugar, honey, corn syrup and maple syrup. I'm inclined against anything but white sugar -- corn syrup contributes to gumminess, I think, and the others all contribute unwanted flavors for what I'm hoping to achieve in the way of pure fruitiness. I'm willing to go out and get some agave syrup if somebody recommends it highly. Honey might go well with peaches, and I'm also thinking of a honey-peach-bourbon combo, but I want a pure peach as well.
The ice cream is unlikely to be eaten too quickly, so I need to be able to keep it frozen without too much deterioration.
If it matters, I will be churning the ice cream in a canister-style electric ice-cream maker.
Last edited by
LAZ on July 24th, 2013, 11:22 pm, edited 1 time in total.