FYI, I did read that casings should NOT be stored in the freezer - only in the fridge at less than 40 degrees F. Not sure if that is true - but did read it on more than one site.
Oh, I so wish my in-laws were as thoughtful as the folks here. As soon as they smelled it, they threw it away!
I kept saying, "Hey, this isn't a rotten meat smell. Let's find out about it first." But, alas, that isn't their nature. So, a full afternoon's labor, $30 of meat, and 6 months of yummy meals for the family down the garbage chute.
I really don't know if it's the casings or not. I've been to several sites and haven't yet found anything about this. The closest I found was one site that said when they are shipped to you they can get smelly - they described it "Kind of like a crowded room of bean farmers after a bean banquet." They went on to describe how to remove the smell. But, none of the three women making it noticed a smell the day they made it - Wednesday. By Friday, when we picked it up, it was starting. By Saturday night (it was frozen by then), it was overwhelming.
I'm not sure if this is how I would describe it (as bean farmers, etc.), but maybe that's what it was. I wasn't there and the three 75-85 year-old women don't remember who had what casings how long and from where, lol. I heard today that my MIL thought that some of the casings were only 2 months old and that her sister's sausage was made in that. My MIL's was made in the older casings (we think). From what we know, her sister has not noticed a smell at all. She froze hers immediately and hasn't taken it out yet. My MIL won't tell her sister about it or ask and has made us promise not to tell.
I am also looking forward to the research with the sausage folks. Thanks for checking.