For several years I've been looking for the perfect vessel to boil water in. Currently I'm using a very old Pyrex teapot (Flameware #8446; it's listed in this cool
1955 Pyrex catalog), which I love except for one serious problem: the handle is too small for my hand so I sometimes burn my knuckles, even after years of practice.
I considered a Revere Ware whistler like the one that served my mother (and you) so well. Searching for an old 2-⅓ quart model, I (and you) quickly realized older is better. What you really want is pre-1968, the year Revere Ware products were "redesigned" (i.e., cheapened). I'm not certain this redesign included the tea kettle, but I'd be willing to bet a 50-year-old kettle would be more substantial than even your's from two decades ago. Of course, eBay is probably your best source. If you go this route, you should probably spend a bit of time familiarizing yourself with how to identify the good stuff (
this and
this are good places to start). I finally decided against Revere Ware because I prefer an open design I can see into and clean.
I've used electric kettles before and like them. I thought about getting a $25
Hamilton Beach 40880, the budget pick of
The Wirecutter, a NY Times-affiliated product rating site I like. I finally decided against an electric kettle because I don't want to give up any of my precious counter space.
As I continue my search for the perfect kettle, I'm reminded of an interaction with Fred Bridge in the 1970s, when the legendary New York kitchenware dealer briefly had a store in Chicago (it's worth reading
his NY Times obit). While Mr Bridge was helping me select a knife, a woman entered and asked about tea kettles. "Use a pot!" he bellowed (NYT: "brusque and contentious, with little patience for those who he felt were wasting his time"). The poor woman tried to explain she was looking for a Copco or similar. "You have pots, don't you?" he continued at high volume, as she hurried out, looking scared. Though Mr Bridge strongly approved of my choice of knife – a heavy French
cuisine massive imported under his name – I have to think he'd be disgusted with me now for not being satisfied with using a pot to boil water. I'm even thinking about getting a 1970s Copco!