First off, apologies to Cathy2 for my inadvertent hijacking of this thread.
Next, my response to Binko is simple: The examples you've provided are specifically for "skinny" burgers; those old fashioned, mashed on the griddle, crispy, lacy edged burgers you commonly find at Culver's, Steak N Shake, and slightly more obscurely, at Winstead's in Kansas City. Those types of burgers are
meant to be mashed; the mashing contributing to their textural uniqueness. I ain't knocking those Burgers. I'm a big fan--
If that's the type of Burger I want...
What I'm talking about are the 1/3 to 1/2 lb. (and beyond) "Pub" Burgers, along the lines of a Paradise Pup, or Kuma's Burger (although I have no particular love for Kuma, I do respect their efforts). Those big, meaty, juicy beasts of the Burger world should be handled with reverence; allowed to interact with the heat at their own pace, and not thrashed to within an inch of their beefy lives.
Maybe the counterman feels a need to justify his existence. Maybe he thinks I want him to put on a show while he "cooks" my patty. I have seen these louts poke, prod, mash, and mangle a perfectly good piece of cow flesh, all in the cause of making it cook faster. I say to thee counterman, "Leave my Burger alone! It knows what its doing. It knows how to play with fire without any extra urging from you. Take your sharp edged spatula away from my precious Burger and stick it someplace where it will do far more good!"
In short, there's room in this wide, wide world for more than one type of Burger; them that was meant to be mashed, and them that wasn't. Enjoy them both, but never confuse the one for the other.
Buddy