okay, you got me going. here goes:
Ann wrote:
My standard line, to my kids, to anyone getting married, is "Marriage is important. Weddings aren't."
Actually, what we seem to be coming to here is the basic question - what is the point of a wedding? Not to be confused with, what is the point of marriage?
For a long time, I thought there was no point to either, ex-hippie and child of the 70's that I am, but my Bride slowly and patiently educated me.
The cute answer is that the point of the wedding is to insult Aunt Effie, who introduced us, and then through a series of compromises was excluded from the rehearsal dinner, and then the head table at the reception, and never really was, well, friendly to us again. So we succeeded well.
And many clearly see it as an opportunity to publicly display how well to do they are, and what execrable taste they have. Upon this concept is built the wedding industry. As someone said above, avoid these people like the plague. They will just try to scare, confuse, and exploit you in a moment of great weakness. I think many of them progress to run funeral homes, which work on the same general principle.
But really, it exists for 2 reasons. To publicly declare your love and commitment to each other, and to extort as much money from as many people as you are comfortable putting a little muscle on. In return, those people expect to have a good time (you are not expected to have a good time - be honest, the whole thing is too intense, and you have to pose for all those photos. You can, however, get really drunk and pass out later in the honeymoon suite - No, I did not, and I am saying no more on this!). In the end, you cannot provide a good time for your friends and family: they either know how to have a good time, or they do not. You can put them in a really unpleasant situation, of course, but even then the ones that know how to have a good time will. And the others will be grumpy and blame it on you, even though we all know it is their own attitude that is the problem. So don't worry about them.
Picture the environment you want to publicly declare your love in and go find it. Picture the way you would want to celebrate this event, and go arrange that. And determine how much you want to spend and do it all within that budget. This may limit who you invite, though keep in mind that the guests also contribute money one way or another.
We paid for our wedding, and I think we broke even, all told. Besides Aunt Effie, one good friend ended up in jail that night from the trauma of seeing me married, but otherwise we ended up with some great photos and virtually no memory or knowledge of anything that happened.
15 years later we were remarried by Elvis, in front of our kids, in Las Vegas, and then went out to dinner and a show. The first wedding was hers, and this one was mine, as I had suggested just this style, sans kids, all through planning for the first. The second was better because I got to enjoy it, though I did give in on which Elvis songs, and she chose wrong (I really wanted Heartbreak Hotel and Suspicious Minds, and she was looking for some of the more romantic numbers).
I also had some friends who got married at City Hall, and then we went to Chinatown for dinner. They then traveled around the country and had at least two big parties, one by her family, and one by his. This also seems like a reasonable plan to consider.
Of course, it all goes out the window once you ask family members to contrbute in any way. Then it becomes their wedding.
Have fun!
d
Feeling (south) loopy