Anne,
I'm glad I inspire organization in someone because I am not the best example to lead. I'm really good at acquiring, I just have a hard time giving it up.
I will update you what I have done so far:
I divided my take-out menus between Chicago and Not-Chicago, which I alphabetize while watching television. These are in plain filing manila folders stored in my filing cabinet. I may break up Not-Chicago later, though I am not yet finished.
I also created an Excel spreadsheet with the following columns:
Type (fast food, bistro, eat-in, BBQ, sushi, seafood, diner, pizza, ice cream, butcher, +)
Ethnic (American, Southern, Japanese, +)
Name
Address
City
Phone
Fax
Website
Hours
I will likely add a column for date menu was received. I visited George R at his map business recently. He was showing a menu from a Mexican place in Highland Park. They have been open for a year and already on their second take-out menu with some changes. I noticed George dates his menus. I think at the very least it alerts you to which menu is current.
I know there are some rolling their eyes about the Excel sheet. Most of the information I need on the quick is there: type, ethnicity, location and hours ... all which can be sorted and searched various ways. I did learn something from collecting data: many suburban locations never posted hours while all Chicago locations did. I think in the city there is a greater demand for late hour delivery. Whereas in the (sidewalks roll up at night) suburbs, there isn't the late delivery demand with a general understanding of hours.
When I sorted my menus by city, which I included zip code. I found there were parts of Chicago I visit more frequently than others simply by how the zip codes stacked up.
Just the menus I found in and around my desk, I have 99 entries on my Excel sheet. I keep finding them here-and-there, so the entries will climb. I am keeping another manila folder with menus to be added to the database. Hopefully I will misplace less and find things faster.
I have not yet gotten to the menus. So far they are just sitting in a folder waiting for my attention. I do like your idea of using the plastic sleeves and mounting them into a ring-binder. It's quick, cheap and very accessible ... I'm glad you added to this discussion.
Happy sorting!