Geo wrote:Here's a question that someone--most likely Antonius!--can help me with. In Germany, all bars have what they call Magenbitters, bitters for the stomach, as in, medicinal. They hang from a placard in c. 25ml dose-bottles. I've never tried them, but I wonder: are they some special sort of bitters, or might all bitters be considered (in Germany) Magenbitters?
PS. BTW, speaking of bitter drinks, our Milano supermarché has several bitter soft drinks, among which is Cynar from Italy. Sort of an alcohol-free Campari+soda. It is fabuluous with a bit of totally dry white rum.
Antonius wrote:The Italian Fernet Branca I mentioned above, beloved in small doses as panacea by my grandfather, has also -- I believe -- more of a reputation as a bevvy with medicinal qualities than most others.
Antonius wrote:Have you had regular Fernet Branca? Do you have a preference of the Branca Menta over it?
A
Antonius wrote:Have you had regular Fernet Branca? Do you have a preference of the Branca Menta over it?
MLS wrote:Even though they are all bitter, I think of Cynar differently from amaro and Underberg as the latter two are after dinner and after drunkenness drinks respectively. Cynar is more of, or exclusively, an aperitif.
MLS wrote:Not that you would try it, but milk tastes totally different after Cynar.
Geo wrote:The bitter carbonated non-alcoholic soft drink comes in a one-liter standard pop bottle and is branded "CYNAR--flavour from Italy" and is called, simply, "Bitter". It's a *beautiful* bright red color! When I get back to Montreal I'll take a photo of it (I'm in KC as of an hour ago--got to tend my grapes and work on the garden for a few days; things are astoundingly more developed than in Montreal, where I still have nice blooming tulips in my front yard!)
chgoeditor wrote:But it does raise the question...are Angostura bitters and Italian digestif bitters generally considered to be the same thing (albeit interpretted quite differently)? Or is it more coincidence that they're both herb and alcohol-based liquids that happen to have the word "bitters" in their name?
MLS wrote:Technically since amaro means bitter, Cynar and Campari are amari, but neither my Cynar bottle nor the Campari (who own both the Campari and Cynar brands) bottle or website mention amaro for either beverage.
Antonius wrote:Perhaps for marketing reasons they don't want to use the term -- and I must say that since these two are more aperitvi than digestivi, I tend to think of them as a different sort of a thing --
David Hammond wrote:...but I'm not sure if, chemically, there is any difference between "before dinner" bitters and "after dinner" bitters. Perhaps, though these names suggest differences, there are, in the final analysis, more similarities.
Antonius wrote:David Hammond wrote:...but I'm not sure if, chemically, there is any difference between "before dinner" bitters and "after dinner" bitters. Perhaps, though these names suggest differences, there are, in the final analysis, more similarities.
David,
The only difference between the two groups that I perceive is the difference in the level of alcoholic content. Cynar and Campari are not nearly so strong as the typical digestives, I believe.
A
MLS wrote:... but about the word amaro, which prior to Antonious' post I had only thought of as an after dinner digestivo, but he is indeed technically (but I'm not sure vernacularly) correct that both Cynar and Campari are amari.
If one has ever tried them, there is no question regarding bitter.
Campari is a mild bitters-type apéritif, often drunk with soda, orange juice, or in mixed drinks. The formula for Campari is a secret known only to the factory director at the main production facility in Milan. But I can tell you that Campari does contain quinine, rhubarb, ginseng, orange peels and aromatic herbs. These are combined and macerated in a blend of distilled water and alcohol for a couple of weeks