Hi friends!
Thanks for all your input on what/where to eat in St. Martin. Unfortunately, due to logistical reasons (we only had the rental car for a few days due to a deal), we weren't able to eat at every place we wanted to. Nevertheless, the trip was gastronomically rewarding! Also, I was industrious enough to make a MS Word list of your input but was silly enough to forget to print it out and bring it along. C'est la vie.
Anyways, I stayed on the beautiful Orient Bay area (on the French side) and it was just awesome to have a whole week of doing whatever we wanted. We mostly frittered our days exploring the various towns on the island and being beach bums. We were fortunate enough to have missed the humongous snowstorm that hit Chicago around Valentine's Day *woohoo*
The best meal we had in St. Martin was at La California restaurant in Grand Case (St. Martin's restaurant row) on Valentine's Day. We went there pretty early for dinner (~5:30pm) and were seated immediately without a reservation. We had a great table right by the beach, the perfect seat for an ultra-romantic sunset dinner.
We started with the prototypical tropical drink, pina colada and a (really strong) martini. The martini was so strong that I got a buzz when our entrees arrived!
I suggested pizza but my travelling companion was hankering for seafood and wanted to get the seafood specials of the day. So we went with grilled lobster served with three sauces (garlic butter, Creole and cocktail) and the shrimp salad with eggs and smoked salmon.
Both entrees tasted amazing! The lobster was simple but very well-cooked. We didn't touch the cocktail sauce at all because we just loved the garlic butter sauce on the lobster! The salad was also very delicious. The combination of smoked salmon and hard-boiled eggs is a combination made in heaven. Thank you all for this recommendation! For some deluded reason, we didn't get dessert after that. Sigh~ If only we had tried their crepes!
Another place we really enjoyed was L'Escargot in Philipsburg (Dutch side). When we got to Philipsburg, it was around noon and we were so tired from being stuck in traffic, looking for parking and walking under the hot sun, but weren't hungry enough for a full meal. At first, we just wanted a drink and so, headed to the bar. The partner had pina colada (he really loves that stuff) and I ordered their special guavaberry daiquiri because guavaberry is St. Martin's special fruit, mostly used to make the guavaberry liqueur. The daiquiri tasted just like the pina colada but less sweet. In other words, I couldn't really discern the flavor of the guavaberry but hey, the liqueur sure makes a nice pretty pink drink!
We had a look at their menu and thought we might as well try their escargot since we were there. So we chose the escargot in garlic butter. On fresh French bread, the escargot was very yummy. It was super garlicky (I luuurve garlic) and very succulent. And I think the fact that they were literally bathed in butter doesn't hurt either.
Unfortunately, we missed Mario's Bistro in Marigot because I couldn't find it! It's not on the main strip of restaurants and at the time, we were too hungry to look further. We first decided on a place in the heart of Marigot (I forgot the name but I think it's something like Cafe de la Mer) and sat down. After 15 minutes, no waiter approached despite our attempt to call for their attention and a few groups that were seated after us got served first. So we decided to bring our business elsewhere. So we walked south along the main street and my companion wanted to try Claude Mini Club because of its decor. Its ambience is very seaside treehouse-y because two palm trees actually grow through the 2 storeys of the restaurant and through the roof! They were actually swaying back and forth with the wind when we were there.
I was a little skeptical initially because I thought I remembered someone on this forum mentioning to avoid its buffet (but I forgot my list!). I decided to give it a chance because I was famished and also to appease the partner's hankering for dining in a "treehouse" to make up for his deprived childhood *teehee* As someone mentioned on this forum, the buffet might've been bad but our lunch was one of the best we had on the island. We went with the lunch set menu (starter, entree, dessert) and their daily special of chilled cooked lamb and beef with greens. For the set menu we chose the fish soup and grilled red snapper with Creole seasoning. The fish soup was served with toasted bread, a kind of cocktail sauce and shredded cheese. Having never encountered this before, the combination seemed a little weird to me but they went very well together. It was very hot that day but the hot soup somehow helped cool me down a little.
The entrees were also very tasty. The meat was tender and not overcooked at all. The fish, also served with two sauces: Creole and garlic butter, was flaky, simple yet delicious.
The highlight of Claude Mini Club, I thought, was the dessert. We were super hungry that day and decided to indulge by getting one dessert each. We had the lime cake with lime sorbet and the creme brulee (every restaurant in St. Martin seems to have creme brulee). The lime cake was a (somewhat) layered one with a sliver of lime-flavored pastry cream in between. Along with the sorbet, it was moist and very refreshing. The creme brulee at the Mini Club was the best we've had in St. Martin (we had a total of 5!); the custard part was smooth and creamy, the bruleed sugar was of the right thickness and cracked perfectly like it's supposed to when I attacked it with my spoon. I only wish the custard part had been chilled more so it's cooler on my tongue.
Other remarkable eats include the Coco Beach restaurant on Orient Bay beach where we had the grilled steak with frites (very well-cooked and seasoned) and mussels with white wine sauce and (tons and tons of) garlic. I was skeptical about Coco Beach restaurant because another beachside restaurant we tried on our first day was very mediocre. However, the food and drinks at Coco Restaurant were pretty good. We also went to Tap Five, a pizza place in Orient Bay Village where we had pizza with anchovies, green pepper and salmon. The crust was a tad too thin in some areas but was otherwise very tasty.
We also had their very delicious countryside platter, which is an assortment of Italian cold cuts (prosciutto, salame, pepperoni) and soft French cheeses (brie). The meat was yummy with a drizzle of the chili-infused olive oil and the cheese (brie de meaux) was to die for!
Being in the duty free capital of the Carribean, I couldn't resist shopping! I bought a lot of liquor: dry gin, vodka, Cointreau, Irish cream, etc. I loved Marigot's seaside market that sells not only chintzy souvenirs but also, tropical fruits, vegetables and spices! I bought a huge bottle of vanilla extract and a dozen vanilla beans for under $20 from the spice stall pictured below. I can't wait to cook/bake with them!
Overall, I really, really enjoyed my trip to St. Martin. I only wish that I hadn't missed Mario's Bistro and Wajang Doll in my excursions (Yes! Can you believe it? I missed Wajang Doll! Argh!). But still, a week in paradise is waaay better than being snowed in at home!
"There is no love sincerer than the love of food." - George Bernard Shaw (1856-1950) Irish writer.