I have to say that my love affair with this store is quickly coming to an end after only slightly less than a year of it having been opened. One of the things that I really loved about the store, when it opened last summer, was it's very fresh, though albeit very expensive, fish counter and it's dry aged prime beef. I don't each much beef these days due to dietary restrictions. But, when I do, I like to really go for the good stuff, seared and sliced really thin.
Over the past few months, I have personally witnessed the rather unsightly deterioration of the products sold at the seafood counter. What was once fresh and pristine looking now looks old, filmy and dull. More often than not, the department itself gives off a less than fresh seafood smell as you pass it. Case in point: Their $27 a pound "sushi grade tuna". About three weeks ago, I went in and there were three smallish, graying around the edges pieces of tuna in the case. The following conversation ensued:
YPW: Do you have anymore tuna in the back that you can cut freshly for me?
WF Fish Monger: We have some in the case here.
YPW: Yeah, I see. But, it doesn't look as fresh as I like it. And I'd like a bigger piece than those. Could you cut me some?
WFFM: Let me check.
A couple of minutes pass
WFFM: We have some. But, I can't cut it until tomorrow. What we have in the case is fine though. We cut it today.
YPW: It's kind of filmy looking and gray. I'm picky about fish.
WFFM: No, it's really fine. We know our fish here.
YPW: Maybe I'll stop back tomorrow when you can cut me some.
I ended up going to Costco and getting three pounds of very fresh, very beautiful tuna, which I shrink wrapped and froze for what a pound of the graying WF product would have cost.
Last night, I stopped by the Halsted WF location, again, looking for a top notch steak to sear and slice really thin with some roasted asparagus. As I passed the fish and seafood counter, the very unpleasant smell of fish that's beyond its prime hit my nostrils, so I didn't even slow down to take a look. Though I did notice some less than prime looking Copper River Salmon priced at $33.99 a pound.
When I approached the meat counter, and looked at the "dry aged prime" strip steaks, it was really hard to differentiate them from the non-prime (I assume choice) unaged strip steaks that were right next to them. I'm not the most knowledgeable food guy in the world. But, I've seen enough dry aged prime beef (including that displayed in the WF dry aged case behind the meat conunter), to know that what was being sold out front, if it was dry aged at all, hadn't been "dry aged" for many days. It was bright red and colored no differently that a steak in a package at Jewel would look.
What a disappointment. I have learned that I can buy better products, more affordably and support local vendors at the same time.