Dinner Reco for 25

So, have been set out with the task of finding dinner for 25 Staten Islanders and other for next saturday, and seeing how I can't make decisions I would like some recommendations...guidelines:

we are doing italian the night before, its a Saturday night, needs to appease 25 people of assorted ages, along those lines needs to have some pretty tame items (marathon is the next day, don't want any mishaps)...since they are visitors a somewhat unique experience would be nice but not required...can't get too expensive

A Greek restaurant in Greek Town would be a good choice, meets all of your criteria and you can probably still make a reservation for such a large group at this late date.

You'll find a complete list in this topic.

Good call on Greektown, didn't even think of that...although I have been pretty disappointed to the Greek I've gotten there I think that might be the most convenient option.

I take that back, got vetoed, somehow Greek has now been classified as "weird" and "ethnic"...frown