We received an email coupon for 50% off at Ai, so we thought we'd give it a try tonight. Overall, we were really impressed.
We started off with two appetizers. The first was an otoro tartare that was served on top of some soft tofu and was topped with some scattered salmon roe. Nice and flavorful, but kind of a lay-up. The other appetizer was something really neat. It was an ice sake shabu shabu. We were served a plate of madai sashimi, with some thinly sliced vegetables placed on top of the fish. We wrapped the fish around the vegetables and then dipped the whole thing into an ice cold goblet of sake. After sitting in the sake, we then dipped the fish into a miso sauce served in a separate bowl. Really different, and really good.
We then moved on to some sashimi. Fatty salmon (just ok, unfortunately it had been torched, a treatment that was not advertised on the menu), shima aji (very good, one of my favorites), goldeneye snapper (unlike other snappers I've had, but very good), and otoro (served WAY too cold). Fish quality was above many other places. The cuts were a bit on the small side.
After sashimi we got one cooked item. Shell-on shrimp that had been baked in a salt crust with some rosemary. They cut the salt crust open at the table, making for a dramatic presentation. The aroma from the shrimp and the rosemary was a real treat. The shrimp themselves were very good, nicely picking up both the salt and herbal notes. Unfortunately you only get 5 shrimp for a dish priced at $15. A good dish, but I'm not sure it was $15 good.
To finish things off we got two maki. The first was crunchy salmon. Crab (with a C, not a K), cucumber, and avocado on the inside with salmon on the outside served on a bed of tempura crunchies. I really liked this roll, but I'm a strong believer that most things are better with tempura crunchies. The wife thought that this was the best roll she's ever had. The second roll was madai carpaccio. I forget what was on the inside, but the outside was madai with some sort of Japanese pepper and a bit of cilantro. This one was just ok, not nearly as good as the crunch salmon. One neat thing is that you get a "seasonal accompaniment" with each roll. With the crunchy salmon we got some diced madai mixed with tempura crunchies. With the madai ceviche we got salmon ceviche.
So, overall we really liked the place. It's definitely pricey, but I think that's mostly a function of the neighborhood it's in. The space is really lovely, apparently the new owners (the folks who own Ringo and Tsuki) didn't really need to do a lot to change it from the previous sushi place to occupy the space. Given the quality of the food, the atmosphere, and location I can see this place getting very hot once word of mouth gets out.