Home-made pasta is a wonderfully delicious treat, that seems to be relatively hard to find in Chicago. Making pasta is such a lengthy process, but the result is so far superior to processed pastas. So, if I am going out to a restaurant for pasta, I prefer to only have freshly made pastas.
I have been to Gioco, Merlo on Maple, Luna Caprese and Riccardo Trattoria. Of the four, I would not return to Gioco. I found the pasta to be less than average. I ordered the handmade pasta with braised wild boar, and found the sauce to be just too heavy.
Merlo was alright. I enjoyed my beef carpaccio here, and I found the pasta here to be about average. I ordered the handmade tagliatelle with marinara sauce. It had a good flavor, but overall it was nothing particularly special. The atmosphere of the restaurant was too pretentious, the wait staff unhelpful—combined with the average food, I wouldn’t recommend a return.
Luna Caprese was quite enjoyable. I shared two pasta dishes and liked both of them (wish I could be more specific here, but it was over a year a go).
Riccardo Trattoria had by far the best hand-made pasta. I ordered the tagliatelle with a rabbit ragu. It was delicious! The pasta had the right amount of firmness combined with yield, and great flavor (perhaps this varies depending on the flour?). I also had the tuna carpaccio, and the beef carpaccio, both of which were excellent. My friend had the hand-made tortellini filled with spinach and sheep ricotta cheese in a butter-sage sauce with Parmesan, which he loved. The restaurant itself was pretty charming also.
Riccardo Trattoria
2119 N. Clark St., Chicago
(773) 549-0038