I find Christmas dinner much harder to plan a menu for than Thanksgiving. Partly I've simply been doing one myself for a lot longer than the other, but partly it's because T-day is so set, you do variations on a pretty tight set of themes, while Christmas... I can do anything, except it's anything within a style of cooking mostly alien to me (Ye Olde English Large Expensive Beef). So I dithered on a menu until quite late in the day, and still have some ingredients I never used because I kept changing my mind, but here's what I served:
As noted
here, I had 12 Nantucket Bay scallops, what I didn't have was an oven free at that point for the recipe Santander linked to, so I heated a skillet way way up with some butter and wine, sauteed shallots and some little slivers of jamon serrano, then pan-fried the scallops for a few short minutes and served them with a frisee salad. They were pretty terrific and made a very impressive starter for my wife and my sister, both scallop fans.
Main course was standing rib roast, pretty much per the standard Wiviott 5-Step method on the WSM-- I actually wanted to try oven-roasting this year, but I finally decided that it would take too much juggling of other stuff in terms of oven occupancy and timing. Anyway, that turned out beautifully, and alongside it we had two dishes from the Balthazar cookbook which both came out beautifully, a classic potato gratin and a really good pan-roasted root vegetable dish, simple as all heck but everything caramelizes a bit and it's terrific. Plus Parker House rolls (not as good as Josephine's) and, the kids pretty much have to have it at holiday meals, canned cranberry jelly.
Dessert was a bit of a headache. It's an Austrian apple wine-cream (Weinkrehm) tart from
The Pie and Pastry Bible. Supposed to be basically a lemon-wine-vanilla chiffon, poached apples on top, a walnut-cookie-crust below. Too many things I hadn't done before done too quickly and without reading the full instructions-- I didn't put parchment down so the pie weights sank deep into the crust and had to be plucked out with tongs, I let the apples go a moment too long and they made mush, I did something wrong and the chiffon never really set, it basically became a runny cream filling... and yet for all that, it tastes really great, the delicate interplay of wine (a Michele Chiarlo moscati d'asti, picked up inexpensively at Costco), vanilla bean, apple and lemon was pretty wonderful. I can't wait to make it again (probably with a traditional crust) and do it right this time.
[/url]