It was outstanding.George's discussion of maps and prints added a lot to the atmosphere, and I always forget how good Jilly's is. For those who haven't been, it's a small place - reminds me of Le Bouchon, but about 1/2 the size with more space between the tables. The pear poached in red wine salad, with blue cheese and walnuts, was a nice starter, accompanied by Domaine Ste Michelle brut - not great, but certainly a good way to start. The citrus-dusted scallops and spinach timbale was an outstanding dish - it's amazing how firm and meaty the dry scallops were. And the creaminess of the accompanying Markham Chardonnay matched well with the beurre blanc sauce on the timbale. Third course was a Shiraz (forgot the vineyard) with the herbed lamb - cooked rare, five meaty ribs - if it was a more casual space, I would have picked up the ribs and chewed off every little bit of meat. But as it was, I was getting filled, so I let my more refined sensibilities take over (after all, they don't get too much use).
I'd never been inside George's gallery before, but it reminded me of places I've been on Portobello Road in London. Sadly, I was too full to sample the exquisite-looking petits fours.
Considering the free-flowing wines and the quality of the meal, the $49 price (before tax and tip) was a real bargain. Hats off to Chef Brian and to George R - he really knows how to throw a party!