I'd like to thank those who responded once again. This forum continues to be a valuble tool. A group of 7 adventurous eaters (more adventurous than I thought all were going to be) all agreed that the fabled rueben pizza was indeed worth a try. The location of the function did not move after the mid morning break as planned, so it worked out even better. The rueben pizza purveyor was only a scant 15 minute drive from the site of the function. We called ahead. Here's what it was:
Plain thin cracker pizza crust:
Not a BAD crust. Nothing remarkable. More than likely, a prefab deal.
Sweet / hot mustard:
A honey/dijon most likely. The mustard did not have sinus clearing kick, but it did have that dijon nose to it. The sweetness of this sauce kind of detracted from the product as a whole, but as a whole, it was still "pretty good" to "very good" according to the entire table. All were basically in agreement tho. If there were to be a "next time," the pie would probably be better without the mustard sauce. The mustard sauce was one of those tastes that kind of "wore" on each of us after a while. We still enjoyed the pizza enough to keep taking slices, and kind of scraping the sauce off when we were nearing complete fullness. The rest of the pizza was easily good enough.
Corned beef slices:
Nothing exciting here. I think it was probably a mid grade corned beef.
Sauerkraut
All under a blend of Mozz and Swiss cheese.
Would I get it again? Absolutely, but the mood would have to strike me. All did really enjoy this pie though, and were surprised at how good it turned out to be. We ordered a cheese and snausage as a fall back just in case. The Rueben pizza was far better. The cheese and snausage was pedestrian at best. If in the NWesty burb of Palatine, and you wanna try something a bit different, I'd definitely have it on the radar. I've heard of it offered at other places here and there, but this was my first actual sighting, and tasting. I'm certainly glad I did.
Old Oak Pizza Co
781 N. Quentin Rd.
Palatine, IL 60067 847-359-6444
Quentin and Northwest Hwy.
(It's basically a bar with bar food, pizzas, and a few tables.)
We cannot be friends if you do not know the difference between Mayo and Miracle Whip.