Two apologies: first, for not posting when I said I would. Moving back to the Midwest, preceded by the profound post-graduation emptiness of not having to read 200+ pages a week led to a major decompression. But I’m back and enjoying a slice of chocolate-frosted yellow cake and coffee at Sweet Mandy B’s as I write this. Second, this is a pretty long post. For a quicker read, every restaurant is linked to either it's website or a Google Maps site so you can pinpoint the location. And there are a few photos as, towards the end of my stay, I revisited some favorites just to get a picture.
Without further ado, I offer my story and a summary of cheap eating in and around Boston.
After living in Chicago for 3+ years, I entered a masters program in the Boston-area in September 2006. Prior to that move, I posted on the Forum to ask about cheap dining throughout Boston and specifically in Cambridge where I was living. I got some very good suggestions but found that many of them were still a bit outside of my price range. Beyond the shock of going from a steady income to a student-on-loans lifestyle, I was appalled by how expensive dining [in addition to everything else] was out there. Also, when sharing a fridge and kitchen with 2 roommates, in addition to an unpredictable schedule and my cookware in storage, it was tough to frequently prepare great meals. So I did what any self-respecting eater did: I found cheap and good things to eat.
That, in and of itself, became a problem. In my opinion, Boston and its metro area is not as food-friendly as Chicago—it’s a tough town to get around in without a car; there are fewer areas with a high restaurant density; and many of the options in highly-trafficked areas are either of the overly greasy, tasteless, or mundane variety. Further, reasonably priced but nicer restaurants—like a Spacca Napoli or Hopleaf—are tough to come by. There are also a lot fewer resources for finding great food…food writing and restaurant reviews in local papers and magazines are lacking intrepid culinary scavengers and, of course, there isn’t an online site like LTH. With all respect to HiddenBoston, I found Chowhound
Chowhound's Boston Boards to be pretty unnavigable [ditto the
Boston Globe's website and
Yelp], although the
Phantom Gourmet [phantomgourmet.com],
urbanspoon.com, and the
Boston Magazine’s “Best of…” websites were easier to use and occasionally helpful.
My criteria for inclusion: I enjoy eating there and I’d likely continue to eat there even if it wasn’t in Boston. So I’m trying my darnest not to say, “oh, this is good for Boston, but wouldn’t hold up in Chicago.” However, there are three disclaimers:
Disclaimer #1: this list shouldn’t be seen as exhaustive or definitive. 90% of my travels were confined to Boston, Cambridge, and Somerville due to cost, time, and lack of car. Some of the places recommended to me I couldn’t get to. So there very well may be better places so please feel free to contribute to and amend this list.
Disclaimer #2: With two exceptions (East Coast Grill and Carmen’s) everything on this list will cost less than $15 a person, with an average meal in the $8-10 range. I’ve excluded a place like
Neptune Oyster, widely regarded as one of the best raw bars in the city, if not the East Coast, because although a ½ doz would cost around $15, that’s hardly a cheap meal.
Disclaimer #3: Not a big Indian-food person, so that’s one cuisine which, although in abundance in the Boston-area, won’t be represented here.
And, for what it's worth, the five restaurants I'd give the Boston equivalent of the Great Neighborhood Restaurant award to are:
Coast Cafe
Blue Ribbon BBQ
Kantin (in the Super 88 Food Court)
Petsi Pies
Armando's
Honorable Mention: Deluxe Town Diner; King Fung Garden; East Coast Grill; Hi-Rise Bread Co.; Tacos Lupita
AmericanCharlie’s KitchenTavern-atmosphere with patio; good craft beers on draft; the best clam chowder I found in the city; good comfort-food style dinners (pot roast, pork chops, etc).
East Coast GrillOne of the best restaurants in the area, I ate here on 3 occasions, all of which involved either someone else paying or a discounted bill. Bar makes for great solo dining. Excellent tropical-style drinks and wine selection. Very nice raw bar with 4-6 oysters, clams, and shrimp. Delicious, unique seafood preparations (approximately 8-10 different fish dishes daily) and BBQ (particularly tasty chicken and ribs) with saucing that runs from sweet to Asian-inspired to extra spicy. Homemade pickles are a highlight of every meal.
Brookline LunchMy go-to spot for cheap, tasty breakfast. Owned by a Turkish couple, the bacon-and-eggs dishes are accompanied by a hearty, lightly grilled hash browns and vegetables. Fluffy, sizable omelets are topped with veggies and meat rather than placed inside. My favorite part of every meal is the homemade chili sauce and a strawberry-hibiscus-cinnamon tasting jam.
Deluxe Town DinerClassic “rail-car,” short-order diner with counter, but the menu consists of classics with a twist. Sweet potato pancakes with pecans or chocolate chips and blue corn johnnycakes are among the 4 or 5 different types of griddle cakes available. Hands down, the best corned beef hash I have ever had—obviously “corned” in-house, cut into strips and grilled with a few onions and carrots for flavor, potatoes on the side. Go on a weekend morning to watch what can only be called a ballet as the cooks pump out orders on a grill with 20 or so orders on it at any time. Just a taste of that can be seen in this picture:
Charlie’s Sandwich Shoppe This is one of the places the James Beard Foundation has given it’s “American Classic” award to, so that in-and-of itself makes it worth the visit. The décor hasn’t changed, I’m sure, in 70 years. The food, while not as good as Deluxe Town Diner, is tasty—pancakes are fantastic—but the unique smoked turkey hash is the star of the menu.
Blue Ribbon BBQ Great BBQ is tough enough to do but put it along fantastic sides and you’ll always have a place in my heart. Spareribs, pulled pork, KC-style burnt ends, chicken, and (with apologies to Smoque and Honey-1 fans) the best sausage I’ve had in a long time--slight smoke, juicy, nice pork flavor. Collard greens, baked beans, black-eyed peas, okra, cornbread salad, cole slaw.
ProvisionsFormaggio Kitchen A really nice grocery with bakery and deli. Ideal for picnic planning. On the weekends, they pull a grill out front and serve Niman Ranch ribs, various sausages, and other great meats for lunch.
Super 88 Market There are a few locations of this Asian market, but it has the best selection of fish and produce I found in the city, as well as a full selection of various Asian staples. The location I hyperlinked was my favorite because of the food court. I’ll highlight two stalls below (Kantin and Pho Viet) but others represented serve Korean, Indian, Taiwanese, Thai, dim sum, bubble tea, Asian-style frozen yogurt.
Dave’s Fresh PastaMakes great pasta and sauces to go, but I’m a fan of their sandwiches, which had the best meat selection I found in the area. Here’s their version of a muffaletta—great olive salad, salami, cappalcola, and ham with provolone on freshly-based focaccia. Zapp’s chips gives it a nice New Orleans touch. Delicious (and big!) cherry peppers accompany:
Bakeries: Non-LunchClear Flour Best bread in the area.
Petsi Pies Best pies in the area (in addition to great cookies—snickerdoodle, apricot chocolate chip—scones, and muffins). Daily offerings include a Michigan (montmorency) cherry, four-berry, sweet potato, bourbon-pecan and chocolate-pecan. Two locations, go to the Somerville spot for a better selection.
A glimpse of their selections:

And up close and personal with the chocolate pecan pie:
Mariposa Bakery It’s pricey and the service might be among the worst I’ve experienced in place where you order at a counter, but they make amazing pretzel knots, scones, and muffins. Sandwiches are also very good.
North End Bakeries of
Mike’s Pastry and
Modern PastryThe go-to spots for Italian pastries in Boston. Not the best I’ve ever had, but when you are in the mood, they’ll more than do.
Bakeries: LunchHi Rise Bread Co.Offering breakfast on the weekends and really fantastic breads, brownies, and cookies, the thing to do is get a sandwich…they have about 20 to choose from, including veggie and seafood (tuna, shrimp salad), as well as a nutella and chocolate brioche sandwich which I was never brave enough to get. Reminded me of the sandwiches offered at Zingerman’s in Ann Arbor. But what I did order on 3 separate occasions was the best Cuban-style sandwich I’ve ever had—carnitas-quality pork with smoked ham, provolone, spicey mayo/mustard, and sliced cornichons on thick grilled bread. Here it is in it’s porky goodness. You probably won’t finish the whole thing:
Flour Bakery Stuffed breads with meat, cheese, and veggies, chocolate-chip American macaroons, Chunky Lola cookies (nuts, coconut, chocolate chips, oats, raisins), mochas that use house-made chocolate sauce, and really fresh, incredible soups. Two locations.
Mexican/Caribbean/South/Latin AmericanTacos Lupita This hole-in-the-wall Mexican/Salvadorian joint was the only thing I found that could replicate the best Chicago taquerias. Homemade tortillas. The salsa verde is made there too, but the salsa roja, with its wonderful smoky, cinnamon taste, is something I could drink it by the quart. Mexican coke available.
Homemade sopes el pastor:

With the cinnamon-y, smoky salsa roja:

And, an ominous warning to the cheap eater:
Izzy’s Goat stew. Lechon. Spot-on rice and beans.
Coast Café I wish I’d have discovered this spot more than 6 months ago. This take-out spot is part-Caribbean, part-soul food (a very small counter has half a dozen Caribbean hot sauces) serves fried chicken that’s in my top-ten list (and my mom’s from the South so it’s no joke) and the best banana pudding I have ever had.
ChineseKantin – Super 88
As alluded to above, this is one of the Chinese food stalls in the Super 88 market. Another relatively recent find, I’d call it “Sun-Wah East” for its spot-on Chinese-style BBQ—roast duck and pork, crispy pork belly, and just salty enough soy-chicken. Great egg rolls. Great veggies. And, when in season, soft-shell crab over rice.
The Triple Delight:

The roast duck, with its glimmering, crispy skin:
Hong Kong American-style Chinese in Harvard Square. When you want that kind of thing, I don’t think I’ve found a better spot even in Chicago. Recently renovated their dingy dining room, which I think had more character before modernizing.
The sesame chicken, pork-fried rice, and egg roll:
Hei La Moon Along with restaurants in the DC and LA areas, the best dim-sum I’ve ever had. Carts, not made-to-order, but it’s so busy that everything stays fresh. Get there after 10am on weekends and be prepared for a lengthy wait.
King Fung Garden A you-blink-you’ll-miss-it restaurant. Noodles that can’t be beat. Wonderful lamb dishes. Supposedly the best peking duck in town (but I didn’t have the pleasure of sampling it before leaving).
VietnamesePho Viet Another of the Super 88 market food court stalls. Bahn mi, noodles, and pho that rival Argyle Street. Strong and tasty Vietnamese-style coffees with condensed milk.
JapanesePorter Exchange Mall This small mall has a food court entirely devoted to Japanese food. Around 7 different restaurants from higher-end to “fast-food.” Rice bowls and currys bring in a lot of Japanese from nearby universities. My favorites are Bluefin for cheap yet very fresh (and creative) sushi and Tampopo for katsu-don, corn croquettes, and tempura.
PizzaPizzeria Regina Widely considered the best pizza in the city (which means waits at night and on the weekend), the pizza is coal-fired, making for a super-crisp crust with blubbly, dark spots. The toppings are top-notch. The giambotta pizza (sausage, pepperoni, onions, multi-colored peppers, mushrooms, and basil) is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had.
Armando’s A slightly-sweeter crust than Regina and more New York-style, this was my go-to pizza takeout spot. Only downside is that if you take it to go, because everything's so hot when it leaves, the box steams and the crust gets soggy. Another 10 min on a hot pizza stone should fix it, though. Armando himself chats you up and offers the kids cookies.
Pinocchio’s Roman-style squares of pizza. Buttery crust that melts in the mouth. Not always what you’re in the mood for when you think of pizza, but the best when you do want it.
ItalianCarmenI didn't get a chance to have a lot of Italian, although there are PLENTY of spots from which to choose. However, in another "wasn't picking up the check" situation, Carmen was an amazing experience. In the North End section but off the tourist-flooded Hanover Street corridor, Carmen only has space for about 20 people. Super romantic space. Food is Tuscan-influenced. Great small-plate selection; perfectly-executed entrees. I went with three friends who are quite knowledgeable about wine and they said it was among the best Italian-focused list they'd ever seen. This should be a destination spot if you're looking for a great meal and are willing to spend a little (it's truly reasonably priced given the quality and location).
Ice CreamIt still strikes me as inexplicable why Boston seems to LOVE ice cream. Any of these spots are great. Herrell’s might be the creamiest, Toscanini’s the richest and most creative (and, sadly, the stingiest on their scoops while being the most expensive), and Christina’s doing the best job showcasing single flavors. Toscanini’s also does an interesting brunch on the weekends with berry bread pudding, creamy egg sandwiches (one of the best things I tasted in Boston) and great pancakes.
Herrell’s Toscanini’s Christina’s Greek/Mediterranean/Middle EasternGreek Corner Delicious gyros; fresh cut fries. Locations in-and-near Harvard Square.
Moody’s Falafel Palace Great lamb and chicken shawarmas, hummus, and falafel.
CoffeeNothing comes close to Intelligentsia in my book, but Uptown place makes spot-on espresso. Diesel actually serves Intelligentsia coffee, makes great drinks, and is the best atmosphere. True Grounds also has great atmosphere and latte art.
Uptown Espresso Diesel Café True Grounds ThaiDok Bua Best Thai in the area. Huge menu. Both northern and southern-styles are well-represented. Super fragrant. Nice fish selection too.
LackingMexican: I mean, we are SO spoiled in Chicago.
Latin/South American: ditto
Burgers: Nothing comes close Kuma’s, Rosebud, or about half a dozen other spots. You might hear otherwise if you visit. Respectfully, I wouldn’t try to seek out any burger spot in the area.
Italian sandwiches: This really surprised me. I would have thought that the sandwiches at
Italian delis and other spots would frequently be great. Instead, they almost always disappointed.
Most overrated:
Zaftigs. A lot of people might point to this as the best breakfast or the best deli. Don’t get me wrong…the food is good. But it’s not the best. And on the three occasions I went (breakfast, lunch, and dinner) the service was quite subpar. And it’s really expensive for what you get. I’d save my cash and go to Manny’s or the Bagel in Chicago.
Last thought: I missed the boat on Brazilian/Portuguese dining. Supposedly, it’s outstanding. If anyone has anything to contribute in this area, I’d appreciate it.
Anyway, hope this is helpful to Chicago ex-pats in Boston or soon-to-be visitors. Again, would appreciate anyone's thoughts, additions, or critiques.
Last edited by
cjkrautk on June 5th, 2008, 3:10 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Homer: Oh, God, why do you mock me?
Marge: Homer, that's not God. That's a waffle that Bart threw on the ceiling.
Homer [contemplatively, to waffle]: I know I should not eat thee, but...[takes bite]
...Mmmmmm. Sacra-licious.