Cathy2 wrote:Looks like it may still be in business:
Pumps on 12
3085 W Dunes Hwy
Michigan City, IN 46360
We did the Dunes for Columbus Day, and stopped here for a truly gutbusting lunch afterward. The exterior belies the inside: it's a relatively upscale, touristy place with some low-key gas station memorabilia; has sandwiches and dinners - kind of like what a TGIFriday's would be if it were actually a servicable restaurant instead of an exhibition of crap and excess.
It was fine for touristy. Appetizer of "choke" dip was basically melted cheese and mayo, but it was over deep-fried pita chips which were fun. I had an Italian beef wannabe that really needed a flavorful jus, but was otherwise OK - it was topped with freshly-sauteed red onions and peppers. Unfortunately we were so hungry from hiking that meals were inhaled, and I didn't get to taste anybody else's, but nobody left unhappy. Burgers seemed pretty standard, other members of our party had buffalo chicken in a sandwich or a wrap, both seemed better than serviceable. Kids have the option of a 1-topping pizza, spaghetti, grilled cheese or a burger.
Sandwiches came with fries, but you could upgrade to 'o-rings' or sweet potato fries (or other healthier options that we immediately ignored) The 'o-rings' were really excellent: light crisp breading and plenty of onion inside. I'm not a fan of sweet potato fries but these seemed pretty good - like frites, thin and crispy. They also offered a couple of local beers. I wouldn't go out of my way for a meal here, but it was a nice stop after hiking up and down Mt. Baldy.