Last night I had a forgettable White Burgundy, but I also had a bottle of 1997 Rosso from Gagliole. It was wonderful - firm, structured, good fruit, and just beginning to reach its peak (will probably drink well for another 5 years based on this bottle).
Not cheap, but well-priced - it was about $50 at release. We had it at the Tavern in Libertyville, a place that has, IMO, the best wine list in Chicagoland - and not just because it includes over 1000 different choices, including an impressive selection of Burgundy, but also because of their pricing. This gem cost about $70. Think on that for a moment - a ten year old wine, released (probably around 8 years ago) at $52 going for around $70 now
at a restaurant.
The first time I went to the Tavern they refused to let me open my own bottle, "because of the investment in our wine cellar." Okay, fine (grumble) until I looked at the list and prices. Then I had to ask where the wines came from (it is the combination of wine from two or three places the owners formerly had, including Ivanhoe in the city) and why the prices are so attractive (because "this is not downtown and we want to sell these wines.")
If you choose not to go because you don't want to spend $70 on a bottle of wine - reconsider. They have many, many bottles in the $20-$30 range, some of which are pretty interesting. Can't say I have tried them because they have amazing choices in the $50-$100 that are not only half the price (or less) you would pay elsewhere, but are almost impossible to find anywhere else.
As for food, they seem to specialize in sauteing in garlic and butter, often finished with a touch of truffle oil, or broiling steaks. Decent seafood selection, including a reliable soft shell crab special, good list of steaks at reasonable prices (choice or prime, with one each Wagyu and Uruguayan grass fed) ranging from about $30 to $65 for the Wagyu. The food has been reliably good, if uninspired, but the place belongs here because the wine list is so good. The Uruguayan, grass-fed strip is an interesting piece of meat, both in terms of flavor and texture - more of a livery, meaty flavor with a chewy, coarse grained texture, versus the buttery, silky texture and cleaner beefy flavor with corn-fed beef. I enjoyed it and am glad I sampled it, though I will not be searching it out again.
The wine is the star, and the food is a good supporting character.
Will cross post to
this thread, too where Laz mentioned this place with a similar opinion.
Fabulous wine list, indeed.
d
Feeling (south) loopy