seebee wrote:Last year, I swore off yellow peaches from the grocery stores/fruit markets forever.
White flesh peaches are far more reliable. I almost bought a few yellow ones this year, but every time I pick one up, I tell myself, "self, if they turn out to be mealy and mushy, you will be pissed yet again. How many more times before youn learn?" Then, I go get the white ones, and I have yet to be disappointed.
All other things being equal, I find that white peaches have less peach flavor than yellow ones. To me, they taste sweet without tasting particularly peachy. But because white peaches are a more expensive delicacy, you are more likely to see them picked riper and more carefully sent to market. Also, white-fleshed peaches are lower acid than yellow peaches, so they're more edible in an unripened state. Yellow peaches need to be ripe for the sweetness to balance the acidity.
If -- and it's a big if -- you can find yellow peaches that smell like peaches and have a little give to them, they're usually very good, if you give them a day or two on the counter to get fully ripe. If you buy peaches that are hard and scentless, white or yellow, they will never ripen -- they'll only get soft and mealy without becoming flavorful.
But a ripe peach is supposed to be a little mushy and messy and juicy. That's what T.S. Eliot was talking about when he wrote, "Do I dare to eat a peach?" Crispness is for apples.
I have bought good peaches at grocery stores, but they are definitely hard to find. Every time I see a bin full of hard fruit with no scent, I wonder, "Who buys these?" Somebody must, or they wouldn't sell them. Are there people out there who think that those cottony-tasting fruits are the way peaches are supposed to be?