I really love this place, which I've hit a couple of times in the past 6 weeks or so. Today, I made the trek down to Al & Joe's from Deerfield to pick up a bunch of sandwiches for our office lunch. Needless to say, they were snarfed down early and often. I made it back to the office about an hour before we normally eat lunch but that didn't stop 5 of us from making 7 sandwiches disappear before noon. Among our faves were the Italian and the Herbie (Ham, salami, capacolla, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, vinegar & oil). A couple of custom jobs (a wide selection of meats and cheeses is offered) were also very well received.
The bread is excellent, with great flavor and a near-perfect resistance to the bite. You have to tug at it just a bit but the sandwich fillings are never in danger of sliding out of the sandwich. The meats and cheeses are very tasty and in most cases, they're sliced to order (a couple of their more popular sandwiches are made in advance, right before lunch). The giardeniera -- especially the hot -- is fiery, flavorful and full of crunch. Lettuce is torn into large pieces, which work very well on the sandwiches. The overall ratio of bread to fillings is just about perfect. The sandwiches are generously filled but not to the point where the meats and cheeses outshine the bread. There's some very nice balance here.
A couple of large dill pickles were among the best I've had lately and some cracked olives were excellent, although cold sides of marinated mushrooms, artichoke hearts and pasta salad were just ok. Service is excellent and notably friendly. I called in our order before I left the house, so the entire trip from Deerfield to Al and Joe's and back to Highland Park took less than an hour.
Thanks, to all who posted about this place. Turns out my step-brother has been going here since he was a kid (his Grandma lives in Franklin Park) but for whatever reason, he never bothered to mention it. When I suggested trying it out for lunch, after reading about it here, he was all over it like it was his idea.

=R=
By protecting others, you save yourself. If you only think of yourself, you'll only destroy yourself. --Kambei Shimada
Every human interaction is an opportunity for disappointment --RS
There's a horse loose in a hospital --JM
That don't impress me much --Shania Twain