My wife and I have recently sworn off Sinbad's (on Fullerton and Clark,) as they have gone quite a bit downhill in the last year or so. The lentil soup and hot sauce are still good, but the falafels, which used to be so hot they would burn your tongue, has been dry and less than flavorful.
So we turned to Grubhub to find a different place for home delivery and came across Baba Pita, which has locations in Lincoln Park and in the West Loop. Looks like most of the comments here are from the WL branch, but we ordered from the LP location.
Anyway, we've had their food delivered twice. Both times, the food arrived quickly and still warm. The first time, we ordered a chicken schwarma plate, a small order of Baba g, the lentil soup, and a single falafel ball (50 cents each) to test the waters. The chicken was good, if somewhat under-spiced. It came on a bed of light-dill flavored rice. (My favorite version of this is still at Rezas - the only thing I really like there.) The side salad had an interesting mint oil dressing and the side of hummus was decent and tasted homemade with good texture and chickpea flavor.
But the real winners were the lentil soup, the baba g and the falafel. The lentil soup was spicy, savory and filling, with just the right ratio of broth to lentils. The baba was smokey and fresh, with a tart eggplant flavor punctuated by chunks of roasted garlic. The falafel was crispy with a moist interior that was pleasantly spiced.
Unfortunately, the pita was store bought warmed and almost stale. And the hot sauce was, ahem, a bit off to be charitable.
Anyway, just a little bump to help people remember this place. It isn't in the Kedzie/North of the City middle eastern food mecca, but it is close, inexpensive, and good food that (in our case) travelled well.
Baba Pita - Lincoln Park
2233 N. Lincoln Av.
Phone (773) 549-7272