I forgot to post about my experience a few months back at Natalino's.
I thought it was pretty bad.
The food was blah. The service was lousy. The atmosphere was...weird??

Another couple we are friends with are big fans, but we think it's because they live around the corner (mind you we only live about 4 blocks away) and it's convenient.
Everytime it comes up either my husband or I say, "Worst $100 we ever spent."

All around I think it's a loser. Rather inconsistent. None of the dishes were particularly thoughtful. To me it's just kind of slapped together using some template of what an Italian place is supposed to be.

For neighborhood Italian our go-to is Via Carducci on Division. For out of the 'hood Sabatino's, Bruna's or Rose Angelis are our top picks.