In
another thread, ronnie_suburban wrote of the Sam's sale to Binny's:
ronnie_suburban wrote:My guess is that once the sale closes tomorrow, it won't be too long before the shelves at the 2 stores in question are stocked again. That said, the selection at Binny's is good, not great and with no major local competition, it's not likely to improve. Prices will probably go up, too. Where in the past, these 2 entities competed for customers by (in part) stocking more products, I doubt Binny's will bring in any products that aren't very likely to move well.
I was picking up some holiday beers for an informal tasting yesterday, and found the prices at the Whole Foods on Kingsbury to be lower across the board than the prices at Binny's in the old Sam's space on Marcy for the same beers. Granted, the selection was quite a bit more limited at Whole Foods, but it is a pretty well-curated section with a lot of local options. I have not been paying close enough attention to pricing to know whether Binny's pricing has changed for the worse since the purchase of Sam's (I have noticed $3-$4 per bottle increases from about 6 months ago on certain bourbon and rye that I purchase somewhat frequently, but that could be due in part to the liquor tax increase), but I found it interesting/noteworthy that Whole Foods has better prices on beer more or less across the board.
Here's what I got that was on offer at both places and the price differential:
Afflingem Noel (750 ml): Binny's $8.99, WFM $6.99
Three Floyd's Alpha Klaus (22 oz): Binny's $8.99, WFM $7.69
Sierra Nevada Celebration (6 pack, 12oz): Binny's $9.49, WFM $7.99 (on sale)
Jolly Pumpkin Noel de Calabaza (750 ml): Binny's $14.99, WFM $10.99
(While I did not purchase any, I also noted that WFM is $2 per 4 pack lower on Goose Bourbon County compared to Binny's -- $19.99 v. $21.99.)
So, if you're in that area and looking for beer and do not mind the more limited selection, a visit to Whole Foods might be better for your wallet.