Several months ago, happy to see that the Clybourn Costo had prime meat, we bought a package. I reported here that they turned out to be awful. They were full of hard gristle. Mr. Views had a pile of inedible gristle larger than the amount he was able to eat from said steak.
Fast forward to the lovely spring day earlier this week. Mr Views was at Costco getting his new glasses. He decided grilling was in order and he wanted to try the $9.99 a pound prime strips instead of the $25.99 Whole Foods aged strips that are excellent. I don't know if he forgot how bad his steak was last fall or the thought of getting them for $16 a pound less than the aged ones was that enticing.
Either way, I came home from a meeting to find them on my counter top. I wasn't happy. Oh, well. I took the worst looking piece and gave him the best so at least I wouldn't have to listen to him complain. I don't mind sucking off the bits of tender meat from around the gristle. I cut out a particularly egregious piece of thick hard fat from my piece and prepared for the worst. After salting and getting the grill ready, I grilled them and let them sit tented while I finished the salads.
I ate other things first - my baked sweet potato, my salad. He started directly on the steak. "This is really good," he said. Given that last time he was infuriated with them, I was both skeptical and confused. But, I had to eat it regardless unless I wanted a vegetarian dinner.
It was like a completely different cut. It was actually GOOD! Very good. Not aged beef good, but prime meat good. My piece was the worst of them and I did have chunks of interior fat that was gristly to throw away, but it was tasty fat this time and much of the fat was soft. Equally important, the meat was tender, the marbling juicy and tasty, the flavor of the meat rich and meaty.
I don't know what happened that first time. They truly were awful - I think I've had better from Jewel. Along with the tough hard gristle, the steaks were not tender and the flavor was bland and dull. I guess looks can be deceiving even in a cow; I suppose they could have been mismarked and been Costco's main grade of choice, but the taste and texture was more like chain-grocery-store select at best, even though they had decent marbling. I'm just glad that the ones this time were good and I had an opportunity to offer a second opinion. If Mr Views hadn't bought them, I am certain I never would have tried them again.