My wife and I went to Grocery Bistro last night with another couple. I thought I would take some detailed notes and photos, since the place is new. I'll apologize in advance for the lousy photos, as I was taking them quickly so as to not be obtrusive.
The StartersWe ordered three appetizers to share, two of which were specials last night. The first special was the white anchovy bruschetta which was very nice, a bit salty and spicy. We liked the dish.

The second special was seared foie gras with chocolate sauce and strawberries. It's an unusual combination that actually worked quite well, although I ate the strawberries separately.

The third appetizer is from the menu, a steak tartare with a lightly prepared quail egg on top. This was also excellent, although I bit into a couple of whole pepper corns which gave me a blast of heat that isn't otherwise in the dish. A touch of salt would have helped, but there's none on the table.
The Main CoursesThe good experiences with the starters didn't quite continue to the main course.
My wife and I both had the grilled ribeye "filet cut", which is served with baked potato mashed potatoes and green beens. The steak was tasty but about the leanest ribeye I've ever encountered. The potatoes tasted pretty average, and were purposely left with chunks in them to add texture. The green beans were cooked perfectly, but plain.

My friend Craig ordered the chili crusted lamb chops with curried couscous. He had them substitute green beans for the spinach as he hates spinach. Craig reported that the couscous was very good. The lamb was slightly undercooked for the medium rare that he ordered, but it was in the neighborhood. However, the lamb chops themselves had problems. While the bones were frenched, the chops themselves had clearly not been trimmed. There were large slabs of white fat on them. The chops also had sinew or a thick layer of silverskin on them that couldn't be cut through. Proper trimming of a lamb rack should be chef school 101.

Craig's wife Lynn ordered seared skate. Wow, was this dish a miss! Skate is a thin, delicate white fish that should be prepared somewhat simply. This preparation had a heavy, spicy crust on it that made the fish completely invisible. There could have been anything under that breading and you wouldn't have known it because all you tasted was crust and spice. Served with the dish were pickled sweet potatoes, which were also strongly flavored due to the pickling liquid. It was really a poor dish but Lynn didn't send it back because she's not that kind of restaurant customer. We did give them some thoughts on it afterwards however.
The DessertsWe ordered two desserts to share. Both were really good. The first, which I don't have a photo of, was the chocolate chip cookie dough risotto. It was very good, with little bits of what tasted like crunchy cookie in the mix. The flavor reminded me of old fashioned rice pudding.
The second dessert was the PB & J sandwich others have commented on. It too was really nice, served with an orange based sauce that really isn't necessary. This is a must order if you go.
Wine policy and serviceAs has been noted by others, Grocery Bistro is BYOB, which is what drew me to them. As Ronna mentioned, you have to be careful to not let them pour your wine however. The waiter got ahold of our first bottle, a New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc, before I noticed because I was getting settled in and he managed to empty the bottle into the four glasses. Holy cow! I kept the rest of the bottles against the wall on the other end of the table so he couldn't get near them.
One of the first things the waiter announced to us was their corkage policy, which is $5 for the first bottle and $10 for every bottle after that. Craig and I looked at each other with looks on our face that said "WTF?" Corkage absolutely makes sense at a BYOB, but what sense does the extra corkage for the extra bottles make except to just increase profits? I think I might have another answer, which I'll mention below in my wrap-up.
The rest and wrap-upAs noted by Ronna, the place is loud. Actually, it's not just loud, it's REALLY LOUD. We were at a table in the back corner, which I think was better than being in the middle of the room, but we still had to yell at each other to be heard. I don't know what restaurants are thinking these days with this kind of design. They should try putting some fabric on the walls and ceiling and get the decibels below 100.
Another early announcement by the waiter was that they want to take the entire order at one time, including dessert. When questioned why, the response was that it allowed the kitchen to "time the service". Well, it turned out that the timing was to the benefit of the restaurant, not the pace the diners wanted to eat at. The restuarant clearly wants you to eat and leave so they can turn the table. The busboys were constantly on top of us, wanting to take plates if we stopped eating for 10 seconds. The waiter was next to them once when we told them we weren't done with one of the starters and he interjected that the main courses were imminent. We are definitely not people who dawdle while eating, but on a Saturday night we do like to eat at a relaxed pace. We had a 7pm reservation and were back on the street heading home by 9pm, which is not dawdling.
I think this "eat it and beat it" mentality is also behind the heavy pours of your own wine and the increasing corkage fee. If your wine is gone sooner, and you're dissuaded from bringing bottles due to the increased corkage, then you'll leave sooner. I don't know this as a fact, but it's consistent with their actions.
I'll probably wait for 6 months before returning, so that the newness wears off and the crowds subside. At that point, it might be an enjoyable restaurant to visit. However, at this sound level, I won't be back since I like to actually interact with the people I'm sitting with.
John Danza