G Wiv wrote:Matt wrote:The Publican does very good mussels and very good frites, although of three different orders I've had (in three different visits), one was off and was sent back.
One out of three sent back does not seem that solid of a recommendation.
I would think that sample size limitations must apply. A one-third fail rate is obviously not great, but I would want to know if we got the one bad batch out of 100 in order to say whether they should not be recommended. It seems most who have had the mussels in the
Publican thread have very much enjoyed them (some,
rhapsodically so). I have not seen anything to suggest that a bad batch is fairly common, as a number of folks have noted about the Hopleaf. Plus, everything else I have had from the seafood end of the spectrum at Publican has been pristine and excellent; and the one time the mussels were off, it was a textural thing (I assume from overcooking), not a past-their-prime thing (there certainly were no off tastes). Until I hear reports that this is a more regular occurrence as opposed to an isolated incident, I would and will order the mussels again, the one bad experience notwithstanding.