HI,
Yesterday was a pleasant day to drive out west. We took the northern route via 88, then got off at Sugar Grove to take 30 across until 39. Saw lots of windfarms as well as my friend's efforts in Lee County. Passed the site of the nation's greatest mining disaster in Cherry, IL. This year marks 100 years since 269 men and boys died. This is especially stunning when the current population is 500 people. Rene G has more on this story and pictures to follow later.
There must have been quite a line before 4 PM at Rip's, because when we entered the dining room was filled. We were the first party in the second wave waiting for the first to begin to depart. While you are in line, they begin taking your order, which really makes everything move at a rapid pace. The menu is steamlined to the essentials: fried chicken (dark or light), fried mushrooms, french fries and coleslaw. We only skipped the fries. Rip's coleslaw was really crunchy-cold with a sweet dressing on top you mixed in yourself to stem the wilting that inevitably occurs. It was an especially welcome counterpoint to the fried chicken, especially when the chicken grease begins to dull your senses. While some people purchased drinks at the bar, food and drinks ordered at the table brought the bill to $6. each with a generous tip.
When we left Rip's, the line was to the door. The dining room had a number of cleared tables, which didn't seem to bother those people waiting. Our waitress advised the great grandson of the founders is now cooking the chicken. Preparing the next generation to continue the cause.
Across the street at Lenuti's, there were no long lines and enough empty tables to be promptly seated in addition to our party's reserved table. Lenuti's isn't a one-trick pony like Rip's, they do offer a full menu including a lot of regional fish. The menu included bullhead fish, which was very tempting to order. If it is what I think it may be, it is another traditional food, like the turtle, of the Illinois River People. This is food of impovernishment. The bullhead fish is scored and fried in a method allowing ease picking out bones. Making palatable food that is otherwise onerous and unattractive to eat.
I was grateful the table agreed to order turtle at Lenutti's. My first portion seemed like undercooked pot roast, not quite tender. The second was much better, though the meat did need a sprinkle of salt. Lenuti's does cook their turtle in my preferred method: braise first, bread and fry. The traditional Illinois Rivier People method was breaded, fried, then braised for several hours. The once fried crust gives way to a gravy they appreciate, though I find a bit gummy. Visiting Lenuti's allowed whittling down the list of known venues, may be down to two or three that haven't been tasted yet.
While the chicken may not be a favorite. I do appreciate Lenuti's menu that seems not to have changed in generations. This may change, because the business card magnets they gave us have new names previously unknown. I'd like to return for the bullhead, because you never know when there are new owners, the menu may change, too. The cost of this segment included a number of cocktails and beers, it was roughly $10 per person.
When we finally left Ladd, the line at Rip's was not just to the door, it was now on the street. It is clear, Rip's has won the local popularity contest. If confronted with that line, I personally would not hesitate to go to Lenuti's instead. There are other things beyond chicken their menu offered, I would be interested to try.
Smitty's Chicken is so far off the beaten path, you would not likely bump into it casually. Unlike Lenuti's and Rip's, Smitty's highly season's their chicken's breading. The crust was just as attractive to eat as the chicken. The fried cauliflower was a nice change in pace, though it was beginning to look like just another fried thing. The only thud was overcooked mostacolli with a sauce that was just ok. The waitress could not believe nobody wanted to take it home. Ok, the salad bar wasn't great either, though maybe it was better earlier in the evening. I took the chicken home from Smitty's to share with my family. Total charge was $8. per son with drinks included.
For around $25, this was one fine day of eating. To go full circle, I took 80 and 55 back to Chicago.
Thanks to Jim for organizing this. It was too bad people couldn't make it at the last moment, however six seemed to be the perfect number for trying everything we wanted.
Regards,