My friend and I ended up going to The Stained Glass. (Thanks, EvanstonFoodGuy.) And we were glad we did. Started by sharing an appetizer that was basically a foie gras, bacon and sprouts sandwich on toast. Since the sandwich arrived cut into two triangular pieces, sharing was easy, and also enough. It was delicious. The bacon was not too salty, and proportioned to the foie gras so as to complement and not overwhelm it.
We followed that by splitting the roasted apple and watercress salad with blue cheese and glazed pecans, also tasty, and different from anything I've had before.
My main dish was the Alaskan halibut with mussels. No complaints there, either--the halibut might have been cooked a
scoche less than it was, but only a scoche, and was not overdone by any means, and was fresh-tasting, and the broth at the bottom of the bowl was so delicious that drinking it with a spoon and sopping it up with bread was mandatory.
In the potables department, we started with martinis (this is why we wanted a place with a full bar), and the bartender knew how to make them well. With dinner I had the flight of white wines from the Loire Valley. I really like the wine-by-the-glass system. They have many good ones, and you can choose from any of several groupings of three half-glasses if you wish, which is what I did.
The room is handsome, not too feminine which for some reason I had been slightly concerned about (I guess the name of the place and the picture on the website suggested "tea room" to me or something, but the reality was manlier), and the staff was friendly. It's a very handy place to have so close to the movie theater; my friend and I are glad to have it in our rotation now for our semi-regular afternoon-movie-followed-by-drinks-and-dinner mandates, when a movie (in this case "The Hurt Locker") takes us up Evanston way.
The Stained Glass
1735 Benson Ave.
Evanston, IL 60201
847 864 8600
http://www.thestainedglass.com/index.html