stevez wrote:I feel like I might have eaten at a completely different restaurant. I found little of redeeming quality about Art's Café, other than the parking space I found right in front. I'd only return under protest.
...
I'm here to say that the Emperor has no clothes. I give this place no more than 6 months before it folds.
BR wrote:I'm glad Darren72 nominated Pizza Art Cafe for a GNR because it forced me to try it for the first time tonight (although I posted back in November that I needed to give it a try because I live less than a 5-minute away and never even noticed the place). ...
But now I have found what might just be my go-to pizza place in the area. I picked up a #8 (spinach & garlic) and really enjoyed it. There were nice charred spots on the flavorful crust, crispy on the edges, softer towards the middle, foldable in a NY kind of way, ...
whiskeybent wrote: As above, the anchovies are very potent, way overpowering the rest of the pizza with its supersalty anchovy-ness.
aschie30 wrote:whiskeybent wrote:The pizza with the egg in the center (I forget the name as well) - I don't think that was a favorite of anyone else last night, but it was worth a shot. I think we can probably chalk the ordering of that up to the copious BYO that we all brought with us.
That would be the Capriciosa pizza. I'll partly take the fall for ordering that, as I recall yammering on about how I like an egg on pizza and most people don't like it and they're crazy, blah, blah, blah, and then the pizza was ordered.But truthfully, I think a fried egg sunnyside works better on a pizza than an overeasy egg, which was on this one. Besides, this pizza also had ham on it, and I think we all agreed that ham was not Pizza Art's strong suit.
ronnie_suburban wrote:Service was very friendly and enthusiastic but equally clumsy. Even after some of our food arrived, one diner was missing flatware. We had to ask for small plates even after it was obvious that we were sharing. When our waiter saw all of us sharing soup with one spoon, instead of immediately bringing over additional spoons, he said "why didn't you ask me for more spoons?" Um, if you'd been anywhere in sight, I assure you we would have. Plates being cleared were unnecessarily stacked and as such, the oily sauce from the seafood medley dripped onto the table and into my water glass -- an error that was never corrected. I was just glad it didn't get on my shirt (I need no help destroying shirts) or my camera, which was in my open backpack on the ground next to our table. At 9 pm, we were politely hustled away from our table on the sidewalk in front of the restaurant, probably because of some ordinance, but we still had wine in our glasses at that point. Nonetheless, we were sent on our way with no offer to move us inside. A little advance warning would have been nice. One additional thing that irritated me, which may not have had anything to do with the restaurant itself, was that a group of diners next to us -- apparently regulars, as they seemed to know the chef -- kept getting up, walking 10' away from their table and smoking. This happened repeatedly throughout our meal and needless to say, it was a big bummer, as the smoke managed to waft in our direction.
ronnie_suburban wrote:After reading so many positive accounts of Pizza Art Cafe, I'd been looking forward to trying it for a long time. But my experience was nothing that created a desire to return anytime soon.
=R=
stevez wrote:ronnie_suburban wrote:After reading so many positive accounts of Pizza Art Cafe, I'd been looking forward to trying it for a long time. But my experience was nothing that created a desire to return anytime soon.
=R=
It sounds like not much has changed since my visit two years ago. I still don't understand the love for this place.
Kennyz wrote:That said, using the pizzas above in your judgement Pizza Art Cafe is like judging Bari by its boxed raisins and produce section. I wish you'd heeded the advice in this thread before ordering - you happened to order the two pizzas that multiple people in this thread have noted are PAC's weak suit. There are many standout dishes highlighted by posters here, and you seem to have missed all or most of them. Too bad.

Kennyz wrote:stevez wrote:ronnie_suburban wrote:After reading so many positive accounts of Pizza Art Cafe, I'd been looking forward to trying it for a long time. But my experience was nothing that created a desire to return anytime soon.
=R=
It sounds like not much has changed since my visit two years ago. I still don't understand the love for this place.
That's an amusing reaction: post a negative account 2 years ago (actually closer to 3), read pages of positive accounts that counter it, then wait for one more negative review so that you can say not much has changed. Amazing how the human mind works sometimes.
dansch wrote:It just wasn't a great pizza - it wasn't going to hold up anywhere in the same eschelon as Coalfire/Spaca/Great Lake/etc (which, given the style of pizza and oven, is what I would measure against).
I admit it. I went to a restaurant without doing my usual "<restaurant> site:lthforum.com" search on Google and reading all of the posts so as to know which pizzas to order and which to avoid. I sat down, I looked over the menu, I asked for recommendations, I ordered, I got so-so food. If that's a damning indictment of my skills instead of the restaurant, so be it.Kennyz wrote:You asked for recommendations from service staff instead of LTHforum posters who have noted quite clearly that the servers at PAC are clueless.
I see the raging hot wood-fired oven, I guess my expectations (and comparisons) go up.aschie30 wrote:Pizza Art is not, I don't think, attempting to be a Pizza Temple like those places you list. If you read the thread above, in addition to enjoying the pizza for what it is, many people enjoy numerous other, non-pizza dishes.
That's fair. It's a cute place, reasonably priced, BYOB, and has decent food - if I lived a couple of blocks away, I could see going there more regularly. That said, I'm not sure I'd send out of towners there as a great example of Chicago dining.aschie30 wrote: I think Pizza Art's neighborhood appeal is an in total experience, rather than being simply about pizza, a la Great Lake. In that regard, I don't think the comparison is apt.
ronnie_suburban wrote: I would describe what we ate as good, fine or nice but neither exceptional nor great.
aschie30 wrote:Part of the appeal, I think, of Pizza Art is its quirkiness
stevez wrote:I still don't understand the love for this place.
Kennyz wrote:That's an amusing reaction...Amazing how the human mind works sometimes
dansch wrote:I admit it. I went to a restaurant without doing my usual "<restaurant> site:lthforum.com" search on Google and reading all of the posts so as to know which pizzas to order and which to avoid. I sat down, I looked over the menu, I asked for recommendations, I ordered, I got so-so food. If that's a damning indictment of my skills instead of the restaurant, so be it.Kennyz wrote:You asked for recommendations from service staff instead of LTHforum posters who have noted quite clearly that the servers at PAC are clueless.
thaiobsessed wrote:So, as I plan another visit to PAC, I'm trying to pick out the highlights of previous posts (and what appeals to me).
As a rough plan, I think I'll order the crostini with house-smoked beef, a shrimp and homemade chees pizza, and either a diavola pizza or a pasta al amatriciana?
PAC fans, any can't miss standouts I should add?
Kennyz wrote:The cevapcici is quite good too.
ronnie_suburban wrote:Our server immediately nodded his disapproval like a pitcher shaking off a sign from the catcher.
Service may be somewhat slow and clueless, and the espresso may be a bit weak. But Pizza Art Cafe is doing way more things right than wrong.
ronnie_suburban wrote:As for ordering the wrong pizzas/items, I blame Dan entirely
=R=
scanz wrote:ronnie_suburban wrote:As for ordering the wrong pizzas/items, I blame Dan entirely
=R=
Ronnie, don't you know that as a nobody you are going to be served the "average" food...I thought everyone knew that when dining out you HAVE to have a Plotnitwitcki with you, and I'm sure they even would have brought out the special salt cod...or a wood pidgeon



