I'll just throw out there another rec for the Giordano's mail-order pizza. I sent one to a buddy in Louisville as a thank-you gift for his help with my wedding, and as someone who would pretty much camp out at Giordano's whenever he was in town, he was all smiles with his gift. So I offer that recommendation if your boyfriend is equally crazy about Giordano's pizza.
Good luck.
P.S. Also, just an fyi to everyone, when I checked their site just now, it appears that G's has widened their mail-order pizza selection. I could've sworn a couple years ago it was just a cheese or spinach selection, but not they've added pepperoni, sausage, and a veggie to the list. Maybe I'm remembering it wrong, but if I'm not, I figgered I'd throw that out there as a public service announcement.
I hate kettle cooked chips. It takes too much effort to crunch through them.