French Laundry Recap -- September 24, 2009It was with enthusiasm that I accepted the invitation . . . (just kidding).
I had the good luck to dine at French Laundry recently.
MY IMPRESSIONS: I feel like I need to begin by saying that although I’m not a regular high-end diner, I’ve been fortunate enough to dine at Tru, Alinea and Charlie Trotter’s over the past 7 years or so. Therefore, it was inevitable (for me) to mentally compare my French Laundry dining experience with those prior ones. On its face, Alinea seems like it would be the most distinct and different from French Laundry, but really, in some ways, it was the most similar. Dining here after Alinea seemed like a backwards progression to revisit Grant Achatz’s roots. I’m not sure how much he admits to his French Laundry training as a major influence, but at least for me, that was the most apt comparison. (As for Tru, which I enjoyed the least, I felt like its forced formality and attempt to fuse divergent flavors didn’t always work, and Charlie Trotter’s, which I liked better than Tru only because the food tasted better, but again, Charlie’s perfectionist personality and the restaurant’s formality resulted in perfectly executed but soulless dishes that only tampered my excitement.)
Anyhow, it occurred to me that, if you remove Alinea’s modern flourishes and experimentation, at base, its food is similar to French Laundry. If anything, that underscores to me how good Alinea is and perhaps is the reason why Achatz's food actually
tastes good and is not its own victim of experimentation. Relatedly, there is more than a little bit of interest at French Laundry in Achatz as apprentice, as more than one server approached us and asked us with enthusiasm, “I hear you’re from Chicago. Have you eaten at Alinea? How was it?” Some were even knowledgeable about certain Achatz signature dishes, as the one-potato, two-potato.
That’s about all the philosophizing I’ll do about my French Laundry dinner, except to observe how it stayed within the bounds of classic French food and without seeming dated, boring or routine (as I sometimes hear about Everest). Also, the integration of local California or otherwise American ingredients seemed natural and was done seamlessly, and didn’t all undermine the very French theme of the cooking. The dinner progressed bit by bit, each dish subtly and gradually building on the last, such that your palate is soothed, massaged and sated, but never shocked or overwhelmed. In this regard, French Laundry departs from Alinea (or Alinea departs from French Laundry) as sometimes, during my meal at Alinea, each course differed so much that, by the end, I was ready to call “uncle;“ I couldn’t take any more.
WINE: If you can order the wine pairings at French Laundry, I encourage you to do so. In my opinion, it’s always good to put yourself at the mercy of a talented sommelier, if only because you don’t have to agonize over pairing one or two bottles of wine to go with 9+ courses. But also, pairings allow you to dip deeper into the restaurant’s wine cellar than you necessarily would if you ordered off the wine menu.
ATMOSPHERE: From the outside, French Laundry is easy to miss. A very unassuming but charming brick building, you walk along the long side of it into a courtyard to the front door, which is also easy to miss. If you can have a glass of sparkling wine and linger in the courtyard before your meal, as we did, you should -- you can Peeping Tom into the windows of the kitchen (as I did), which peer out onto the courtyard. As with these types of restaurants, the chefs in the kitchen are not screaming at each other, pans clanging. They are quiet, seamless, graceful and focused in their tasks. As for the restaurant, the upstairs-downstairs format and décor remind of Trotter’s, but it is way less formal. Although people are dressed nicely, a cocktail dress would be too formal, and most men wore sport coats, no tie. There is no hushed din to the room, the tables are conversing and laughing openly; in fact, it’s kind of loud in there.
The only sign that you’re at The French Laundry
Entrance
Kitchen adjacent to courtyard outside entrance
Kitchen at work
They’re actually laughing while they work!SERVICE: Service is polished, but informal, California-casual. They don’t hover, but they don’t act as if they’re not there either. They’re not afraid to interact with you, ask if you liked certain dishes, and get feedback.
First Amuse: Cave Aged Gruyère Gougères
I forgot to take a picture of this, but the buttery gougère + strong gruyère awoke your palate immediately, as it should.
Second Amuse: Salmon Roe and Beet “Caviar” cones with crème fraîche.

This amuse built off the last - the strong earthy beet and mildly fishy roe + tangy crème fraîche primed your palate some more and readied you for the first course.
First Course:Diner 1 had “Oysters and Pearls” -- “Sabayon” of Pearl Tapioca with Island Creek Oysters and White Sturgeon Caviar

Surprisingly, this was a warm dish. It was a fun duet of sorts between the tapioca balls and the caviar balls. One bite resulted in a burst of sweetness (surprise!), another bite in a burst of salty fishiness (surprise again!). A great start to the coursed meal portion.
Diner 2 had an off-menu truffle custard with chive-potato chip:

The flavors of this, believe it or not, reminded me of Alinea’s one-potato, two-potato, almost to a T! However, this decadent version highlighted the French skill with eggs, the custard was creamy and ethereally light with a black truffle emulsion over it; it was served in a hollowed out eggshell. I could have downed 6 of these, being the truffle and custard fanatic I am. Another great start to the coursed meal portion.
Pairing: Pierre Gimonnet, Premier Cru, “Cuis” Champagne, 2005
Bread Service: Pain Levain from Bouchon Bakery (down the street), unsalted goat butter from California, Vermont butter salted in-house
Second Course:Diner 1 had Moulard Duck “Foie Gras” Au Torchon (cold preparation), Honey Wine Gelée, Marcona Almonds, Frisée and Golden Delicious Apples ($30.00 supplement)

This was a favorite dish of the evening. The duck foie gras was light but rich. It was served with three different types of salt to accompany the foie gras, including a grey sea salt, a pink salt from a Montana copper mine and a smoked sea salt, each salt interacting with and enhancing each taste differently:
Pairing: Huet “La Mont” Vouvray, 2005
Diner 2 had Salad of Roasted Hearts of Palm, Navel Orange, Red Radish, Mizuna and Ginger Crème Fraîche.

Obviously, the kitchen is not showing off its cooking chops with a salad, but rather, executing a beautiful study in flavors and texture of a classic composed salad: peppery radish, citrus orange and gingery, tangy crème Fraîche played off the star, the roasted heart of palm.
Pairing: La Cana Albariño, Rias Biaxas, 2008
Third Course:Diner 1 had a Sashimi of Island Creek Scallop, Belgian Endive, Pomegranate, Pine Nuts, Red Ribbon Sorrel and Truffle Vinaigrette

This was pronounced as the best scallop preparation ever. This is an example of where the kitchen infuses modern sensibilities by serving a “sashimi-style” scallop but stays South of France with such Mediterranean-style flavors inherent in the pomegranate, sorrel and pine nuts. The scallop had a nice clean astrigent taste that was complemented by the earthiness of the truffles and the nuttiness of the pine nuts.
Pairing: Lopez de Heredia, “Vina Gravonia” Rioja, 1999 (We were excited about this wine -- an aged Rioja white! It was soft, smooth and lush.)
Diner 2 had “Beets and Leeks:” Maine Lobster Tail “Pochée au Beurre Doux” with King Richard Leeks, “Pommes Maxim’s” and Red Beet Essence

This was the most daring combination of flavors all night. (In fact, I tweeted this dish during the dinner and someone commented back something to the tune of “lobster and beets? Blech.”) At first, this didn’t work for me only because the leeks (which were akin to a gremalata) were so oniony and overwhelmed everything. I soon figured out that, in order to make this work, you needed a piece of the potato chip, a piece of lobster, and a smidgen of leeks dipped in the beet essence, and pow! There it was. The sweetness of the beet essence (any earthiness was downplayed in the preparation) highlighted the sweetness in the lobster, the potato adding a slight earthiness and saltiness and the leek rounding it all out. A deconstructed version of a heavier French dish. One complaint was that the lobster was tough - I don’t know if this is a seasonal issue as Maine lobster tail I recently had at a dinner at Perennial was similarly tough.
Pairing: Ramey “Hyde” Chardonnay, Carneros 2006 (The predictable Chardonnay to pair with a butter-poached lobster. I appreciated, though, that the sommelier sourced locally from Napa, although that would be the natural choice with Chardonnay. An excellent example of Chardonnay.)
Fourth Course:Diner 1 had “Beets and Leeks.”
Pairing: Ramey “Hyde” Chardonnay, Carneros 2006
Diner 2 had Salmon Creek Farms Pork Belly., Fennel Bulb, Jacobsen’s Farm Figs, Watercress and Aged Balsamic Vinegar
Funny - I had a somewhat similar dish recently at Boka and although I loved it, though the one thing that brought it down was an overly acidic balsamic vinegar. This was that dish, perfected. Nothing earth-shattering, but a study in how well certain flavors go together such as pork + fennel and pork + fruit (figs) and pork + sweetness (aged balsamic), and the spicy watercress to balance all that sweetness out. It also interplayed the distinct flavors and feel of hot and cold foods in one dish - the cold fennel (which I think was poached, then cooled), raw, textural figs and room-temperature, syrupy balsamic versus the hot pork belly. But it is evident how the prominent sweetness of this dish amplified the more mellow sweetness of the prior lobster dish.
Pairing: Mascarello, “Monprivato” Barolo 2003
Fifth Course:Marcho Farms “Ris de Veau,” Mustard Bread Pudding, Peach , Little Gem Lettuce and Dijon Mustard
Pairing: Neyers “Cuvée D’Honeaur” Syrah, Napa Valley, 2005
This was the only course where the pairing was off. The Neyers is a “full grape” fermented wine (meaning, stems and all), and consequently, had a lot of structure and tannins. The tender sweetbread was quite sweet, and glazed in an almost Chinese food way, and the mustard piquancy was really subdued, so the wine didn’t work. But both the wine and the dish on their own were quite good. Just a misstep, and the only one the whole dinner.
Sixth Course:Snake River Farms “Calotte de Bœuf Grillée,” Sunchokes, Sweet Carrots, Sugar Snap Peas and Paloise Mousseline
This was the one dish in which we were given somewhat of a “spiel” about the purveyor, which was that the beef was sourced the first and finest “Wagyu/Angus” beef producer in the United States. Needless to say, this was an incredible piece of beef, and the preparation felt decadent, but not overwhelming in a Ruth Chris way where the beef is doused with butter, then served with potatoes and creamed spinach and buttered rolls. The beef was the star and treated simply.
Pairing: Chateau Simard, St. Emilion 1998. WOW! This Bordeaux was incredible and felt really special. Gentle, graceful and complex, this wine did not smell -- let alone -- taste, like any wine I’ve had before. Mucho terroir.
Seventh Course:“Berthaut Epoisses,” Swiss Chard, “Vol-au-Vent,” Chanterelle Mushrooms, Sour Cherries and Port Wine Reduction
A bit of tableside prep here. The oozy epoisses, luscious, creamy and stinky, was spooned into quenelles onto the awaiting vol-au-vent. The result was not so much a typical cheese course with cheese and fruit or jellies and nuts to transition you into dessert. Rather, by including savory (mushrooms and cheese) and sweet (the swiss chard, buttery vol-au-vent) and tart sweet (sour cherries), the transition was smoother and less predictable than a boring cheese course. In all, it was a gentle bridge from the mineral- and salt-iness of the beef in the prior course to the sweetness of dessert.



Finished “Epoisses Berthaut”
Pairing: Dubruil-Fontain, Savigny-Les-Beaune, 2005
Eighth Course:Moon Glow Pear Sorbet with Chai Tea Sablé and Roasted Jacobsen’s Farm Pears

This was the palate cleanser. Its assertive floral tones and fresh icy consistency discharged that duty admirably.
Ninth Course:“Gâteau Saint Nizier au Manjari,” Mango-Chili Relish, Mast Brothers Cocoa Nibs, Lime Foam and Coconut Milk Sorbet
Pairing: Királyudvar “Cuvée Ilona” Tokaji 2002

This dessert tasted more routine than it read on paper. It was still good but not mind-blowing.
Much more successful was the Lemon Verbena “Vacherin,” Tellicherry Pepper, “Panna Cotta,” Lemon Verbena Sorbet and Chilled Silverado Trail Strawberry Consommé.
Pairing: [Same as above]
The meringue was crunchy outside, spongy inside and did not shy away from showcasing the somewhat spicy, aromatic and herby lemon verbena. The sweetened acidic strawberry sauce rounded everything off. I love fruity desserts, so I could have eaten three of these.
Mignardises:
Some hazelnut chocolate thingeysA bunch of treats that came in a jewel box with hinges:



And chocolates:


A fitting end to the meal. By serving us playful mignardises (the red-wrappered caramel seemed like a fancy Milk Maid), it was as if French Laundry was making sure we'd go home in a happy, light and uncontemplative mood. Needless to say, everything was delicious, and if those chocolates were sold by the box, I'd pay a good amount for them; they were that good.
I went back the next day to take some daytime pictures:

French Laundry corridor/approach to restaurant
Courtyard adjacent to entrance
Last edited by
aschie30 on October 4th, 2009, 2:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.