Based on all of the good reviews, RAB and I visited Spacca Napoli for the first time last week.
Neither of us were impressed based on our one visit. The service was incredibly efficient and friendly, but the pizza left much to be desired.
The pizzas were quite different from the other Neapolitan pizzas I've enjoyed in the past, mainly D.C. spots
2 Amys and
Pizzeria Paradiso. Like Spacca Napoli, 2 Amys is a member of the Verace Pizza Napoletana Association and has D.O.C. status, for whatever that's worth. I've eaten at 2 Amys and Paradiso may times over the years and have enjoyed both immensely - - lightly-charred, crispy crusts and super-fresh ingredients. I've also enjoyed pizza in Italy, but haven't been to Naples.
There are two problems I had with the pizzas at Spacca Napoli - - the crust and the fairly bland toppings. The crust was doughy, soft, and strangely pliable - - absolutely no crispiness. The char, which was pleasantly bitter, was limited to the edges. The bitterness, however, was strong enough that we would not have wanted the flavor throughout the pizza because it would have completely dominated the toppings. The only explanation I have is that I prefer a longer cook in a cooler oven. Paradiso, for example, keeps their wood-burning oven at 650 degrees, significantly cooler than Spacca Napoli's. A 2 Amys or Paradiso pizza is more brown on top and is crisp, as opposed to the soft doughiness of a Spacca Napoli pizza.
On to the toppings . . .
RAB and I shared the Funghi e Salsiccia (mushrooms and sausage) and the Antonio special (cherry tomatoes, speck, ricotta). Both pizzas were undercooked for my palate, with barely any color on top. I thought the Funghi e Salsiccia was a failure, mainly because the pizza lacked sufficient flavor or salt. I tasted the sausage on its own and it was super-bland, paling in comparison to Burt's delicious sausage. I've actually never had Italian sausage with so little salt. Perhaps just a bad batch of sausage? Combined with the mild mushrooms, this made for one boring pizza. For the first time in my life, I salted a pizza. The Antonio was slightly better, mainly because of the speck, which did add some flavor to the pizza. Still, with the soft dough and the short cooking time, this isn't a pizza I'll be craving.
Based on this experience, we won't be back.
Ronna