ChgoMike:
I’ve become a little gun-shy when it comes to discussions of pizza, a topic which seems to cause passions to run inordinately high. So let me say up front: to each his own. If I use the words ‘better’ or ‘best’ here, they necessarily are intended to bring with them the qualifying phrase “to my taste.”
In making pizza, my goal is to make something that approaches what is traditionally made in Naples and Campania and at Neapolitan-oriented, traditionally-minded bakeries, restaurants and pizzerias elsewhere in the world. That guiding principle can be summed up in my phrase used above and elsewhere on this board:
pizza alla napoletana is “
bread with a little stuff on it.” The crust is the main focus of the
pizzaiolo and the key element of the pizza and as is almost always the case with Italian dishes, the recipe is absurdly simple: this pizza dough is just basic Italian bread dough, i.e., all purpose flour, yeast, salt, and water, mixed and allowed to rise properly (i.e., slowly). This sort of dough is the one that is now part of the DOC regulations for pizza in Naples. If you make your own Italian bread ever, then, just use your bread dough; otherwise follow a recipe for Italian bread from a good Italian cookbook or baking book. Another possibility is to buy raw dough from a baker whose bread you like; Amata and I make our own when we feel like enjoying the kitchen work and buy it when time is short and the focus is on the eating and not the making.
To sum up, traditional Neapolitan pizza is made with simple bread dough which
does not contain any shortening agent whatsoever (olive oil, butter, lard, etc.). In this regard, it should be noted that many recipes for pizza in books published in the States, even in a context of presenting traditional recipes, suggest adding a little olive oil to the dough. Here I’m thinking at the moment specifically of Carlo Middione’s fine book on southern Italian cooking, which contains an excellent recipe for Italian bread but then encourages addition of oil for pizza making. Perhaps this isn’t surprising, given the fact that Middione is from Buffalo and pizza dough with a touch of oil is ‘New York style’ and the norm in basic joints throughout New Netherland (i.e., New Jersey, New York, western Connecticut, eastern Pennsylvania).*
You mention that you’re looking to find a way to make a crust that reminds you of what is common to the Hill in Saint Louis. Unfortunately, I am yet to have had a chance to visit Saint Louis, so I’m not sure what kind of crust they favour but it sounds from your brief description that it may be a take on the short variety which is the distinguishing feature of Chicago pizza and perhaps more broadly Midwestern pizza. What I make is not cracker like; cooked properly the outside rim (
il cornicione) is a little thick, bread-like, which is to say, crispy on the outside and a little chewy on the inside (overcooked it gets tough), and the middle part, where the toppings reside, is soft and pliable but not completely limp (though I will probably never make pies so large in diameter that would be a problem). Getting the central part of the pie to be and stay intact and very thin (to a degree, the dough can contract on the way to and in the oven) is kind of tricky for most of us but one of those things that the accomplished pizzaiolo’s hands do effortlessly.
You refer to the question of the oven and that is indeed a major limitation in making Neapolitan style pizza at home. Over the past few months I’ve been spending a lot of time thinking about bread and dough and ovens and have been doing my best to learn some of the mysteries of bread from Frank Masi (I spent much of my ‘spring break’ at the bakery –– no tan, but the cornmeal in my shoe reminded me of sand). Without doubt, the traditional Neapolitan way of baking the pizza very quickly at very high heat (see the link in the footnote about Lombardi’s, whose oven is regularly at 900 degrees!) is the best way for that style but also something completely impossible for the home cook and even most pizzerias and bakeries. There are ways to compensate for the lack of supremely high heat but they can only go so far. Incidentally, I suspect using short dough for pizza may have started as such a compensatory measure, an idea I think my mezzo-paesano JeffB may have also suggested somewhere (Jeff, if I’m wrong and you disagree, I apologise), but to my taste the shortening alters too drastically the taste and texture of the dough. The use of a pan with thicker crust but made from unshortened bread dough, as is done at the top Italian bakeries in town such as Masi’s and D’Amato’s, works very nicely, thought the final product is different in character from the blast-oven version from a pizzeria.
I find the pizza stone in a 500º oven gives a good result but no charred bits can be achieved without overcooking the toppings and the outer crust, rendering it tough. An oiled pan (used for the green pie above) works nicely too but cooks slightly slower than with the stone, I believe.
***
Ann:
I’ve never tried using the pizza flour you refer to but would like to check it out; next time I’m at Caputo’s I’ll look for it. Do you know how it’s different from the bread flour or all-purpose? I would guess it’s more like bread flour (so all hard wheat rather than the hard/soft mixture that all-purpose is). My research both reading and observing the master had left me with the impression that the difference in final product between all purpose and bread flour is not that great but I’ll follow your suggestion and try the imported pizza flour one of these days.
***
Gleam:
There is some terminological confusion with all the terms for the various related cheeses that commonly find their way onto pizzas. Basically,
mozzarella is in the narrowest sense
mozzarella di bufala, that is, buffalo milk cheese made by the pasta filata method. Traditionally, this stands in contrast to
fior di latte, which is made from cow’s milk and can also be referred to as
mozzarella di mucca. The aged , low-moisture, tangier versions of these cheeses are respectively
provola, made with buffalo milk, and
scamorza, made from cow’s milk. Terminological confusion arises in part here in the States as a result of sloppiness and commercial dishonesty but the above outline is how the terms have been used in Campania. Now, in Campania itself a certain terminological problem arises through the practice of making cheeses with mixtures of buffalo milk and cow’s milk. This practice stretches the very limited supply buffalo milk but is not just a question of that; the mixture produces a cheese with its own special quality which, to the palates of some natives of the mozzarella producing zones, is itself to be prized (not as bland as cow’s milk alone, not as strong as buffalo milk alone).
As I’ve said elsewhere (in the long “Follia/Pizza/Mozzarella thread), here in the States
mozzarella di bufala is very expensive, never supremely fresh (one of the quintessential characteristics of good mozzarella) and often more than a week old by the time of consumption. Given that, I prefer to spend my money on fresh, more or less locally made
fior di latte, i.e.
mozzarella di mucca, for a
pizza Margherita. Scamorza and provola, especially with their lower content of moisture, make great melting cheeses and have a nice tang to boot; I use scamorza in preference to fresh mozzarella (i.e.
fior di latte) on a few things and use it in place of fresh mozzarella if the need arises. Most commercial pizza makers use the industrially produced low-moisture mozzarella (which is texturally like scamorza but generally lacks the tang of a good scamorza made by a smaller scale operation.
Antonius
* At least some of the very best places back east follow the Neapolitan recipe without any fat added to the dough, such as the famous
Lombardi’s on Spring Street in Manhattan (link), which is said to have been New York’s and, indeed, America’s first pizzeria.
Alle Nerven exzitiert von dem gewürzten Wein -- Anwandlung von Todesahndungen -- Doppeltgänger --
- aus dem Tagebuch E.T.A. Hoffmanns, 6. Januar 1804.
________
Na sir is na seachain an cath.