Hi,
If the guys are not willing to travel far, then going to Johnny's Chophouse is the way to go. I was there once after a meeting and have hoped to bring the Moms ever since.
If they were willing to travel and go 12 miles to the west, then
Richmond Hunting Club. They have extended hours during the hunting season, I would call to check they are open when you intend to visit.
Fourteen miles away (just north of Richmond) in Genoa City, WI, there is a restaurant featuring
fishboils. Call to reconfirm hours because it's been a while since I was last there.
Regards,