Had Thanksgiving dinner here last night. I know it's a special menu, and certain allowances have to be made, but I think this place is incredibly overrated (with one very big exception, in a bit).
One of the ways I assess how a restaurant deals with customers is by looking at the price of Veuve Clicquot Yellow Label on the menu. We don't drink it, because I think for anything more than $30/btl it's overpriced, and you'll see that at restaurants exactly zero times. But at Primehouse, we have a new record. $25 for a glass, $60 for a half bottle, $120 for 750ml. Obnoxious. And the rest of the list was pretty much the same. They have a decent selection, but the markup is atrocious (and I'm not one of these people who think everything should be retail + $10---I have no issue with 100% markup. I do have an issue with 200% markup on 2006 Napa Cabs I can get by the case at Binny's).
Our server was fairly poor (for a place to pretends to be nice, anyway). I poured the wine all night, and he was basically there to just upsell.
First food item: a bone-dry piece of cornmeal. I can't believe they served it, to be honest. It wouldn't have been out of place at a Ponderosa.
Four-course prix fixe for $39. Third course is entrees, with a $25 surcharge for 15-day dry aged tenderloin, and $38 surcharge for the 40-day ribeye.
I had a corned venison hash with quail egg to start, which was decent, but the egg was overdone and there wasn't enough of it. With a bit of work, the dish would be good. Second course, frisee with goat cheese, beets, and spiced pecans. Tasty.
Third course, I had the tenderloin. Now here's the thing: my wife and I visited David Burke's probably a year ago or so, and my impression was that they made a killer steak and that everything else was subpar. This did nothing to change my impression. The flavor and texture of the meat are awesome (even though it came out medium instead of medium rare), and the char is just unstoppable. My only complaint is I think the crust is a bit salty; it's quite overpowering.
Dessert was a fine (not bad, not great) apple cobbler.
We had a $79 bottle of South African Cab Franc (which was a *bargain*, relatively), bringing the total before tip to $230.
No thanks. We won't be back, unless I find out the corkage policy is decent and we can order literally nothing but steak.
edit: on the way home, we realized we hadn't been given the promised turkey sandwiches. But they probably would have sucked, anyway.